Newcastle fans are at each other's throats this week, but not over what you'd expect — it's not the Palace collapse that's dividing them, it's Joelinton, with supporters genuinely split on whether he's a striker worth backing or a liability that's wasting their club's ambition. And here's the kicker: whilst the fanbase is tearing itself apart over one player's ability, the narrative about Eddie Howe and squandered investment isn't landing with anger — it's landing with resignation, which might actually be the most damaging emotion of all. The Palace late winner had its moment, sure, but it's Joelinton's future that's become the real fault line in the Newcastle support.
Positive 7.9%
Neutral 28.5%
Negative 63.6%
Newcastle's second-half collapse in week 32 has ignited a powder keg of frustration amongst the fanbase, but here's the thing—the anger isn't evenly distributed. Whilst three-quarters of discussion remained measured and analytical, the vocal minority absolutely lost it, demanding managerial change and questioning where hundreds of millions in investment have actually gone. The sarcasm was cutting, the profanity was flying, and fans were pointing fingers directly at the boardroom, because after weeks of poor form, promises of a response simply weren't materialised on the pitch.
Neutral
73.7%
"@NUFC And another absolutely stupendous second half , wonderful"
Anger
14.2%
"@NUFC Is this the response you promised? Fuck me we've been shite!! SAXK THE CUNT!!! @jamiereuben #EDDIEOUT"
Annoyance
12.1%
"@NUFC Pathetic spinless performance yet again.Our wingers are so fucking poor"
Positive 4.6%
Neutral 32.0%
Negative 63.4%
Here is the thing: Newcastle fans have largely kept their cool after that Crystal Palace collapse, with three-quarters staying measured, but the cracks are showing in that composure. The frustration that is building centres on one specific target — Eddie Howe's tactical inflexibility and the team's complete inability to adjust when their gameplan falls apart, and after a three-week break you'd think they'd come out sharper, not flatter. What is really gnawing at the fanbase is the sense that they know exactly what is coming next: the post-match interview where Howe insists they controlled the game, they were excellent, they created chances — while everyone watching just saw a team with no Plan B, no creativity, and frankly no fight.
Neutral
76.2%
"At least Andy Howe gets another crack at it this summer! Can’t wait!!"
Annoyance
13.2%
"@NUFC Fucking dog shit, 3 week break and we put in a performance like that? Howe needs to go. No plan B. Players look fucked. What the fucks happening"
Disappointment
10.6%
"I give up Howe OUT"
Positive 9.7%
Neutral 32.1%
Negative 58.2%
Here's the thing: Newcastle fans are genuinely torn after that Palace loss, and it's the worst kind of split because it's not angry — it's exhausted. Three quarters of the conversation is just numb acceptance, but underneath that surface calm, you've got a hardcore of supporters who've watched Eddie Howe deliver the highest highs in decades suddenly questioning whether he's the man to take them the final step, whilst an even smaller group is ready to burn it all down calling the manager and players complete shite. The real story isn't the rage — it's the resignation, the creeping sense that something's broken and nobody quite knows how to fix it.
Neutral
73.9%
"@NUFC Never doubted you Eddie great team selection!"
Gratitude
15.1%
"Thank you Eddie. You've given me the highest highs in my 25-30 years supporting the Toon, and you will forever be a club legend for how you turned us "
Annoyance
10.9%
"@NUFC GET EDDIE OUT OF MY FUCKING CLUB. Awful team selection and woeful fucking timing on subs! He’s clueless!"
Positive 3.2%
Neutral 29.6%
Negative 67.2%
Newcastle fans weren't just frustrated by Murphy's performance on the pitch — they were seething about the tactical decisions that put him there in the first place, especially with alternative options like Elanga available and clearly in form after the international break. What really wound them up wasn't a single bad game, but what it symbolised: three weeks of preparation time yielded a genuinely poor display, and the choice to hand the captaincy to an underperforming player felt like a management failure compounded. The anger ran deep because fans could see better solutions existed, yet the club served them exactly what they didn't want.
Neutral
82.4%
"Elanga for Murphy (Elanga also had a great international break but apparently Murphy is just the man to play) "
Anger
10.4%
"@NUFC @AaronRamsdale98 Playing fucking shit btw.. 3 weeks to work with this and this is the dross you're serving?? PUT A STRIKER ON THE PITCH! Osula a"
Annoyance
7.2%
"Murphy was fucking shite and is fucking shite. The fact he was the captain today is an embarrassment- has he won won a fucking raffle or something?"
Positive 40.8%
Neutral 34.2%
Negative 25.0%
Here's the thing: Palace fans weren't exactly losing their minds over this one—and that tells you everything about where this club's at right now. Sure, you've got your obligatory well-dones and congratulations flooding in, but eighty percent of the reaction is just... neutral acceptance. A late winner's a late winner, yeah, but most supporters seemed more relieved than euphoric—this wasn't a moment that united the fanbase in pure, unfiltered joy. The real story here is that when you finally get a dramatic three points, the response is measured, almost business-like, which suggests Palace fans have learned to keep their expectations in check this season.
Neutral
79.5%
"@CPFC Congratulations,nice kick"
Approval
10.2%
"@CPFC I’m so grateful we have Mitchell."
Anger
10.2%
"@CPFC Terrible defensive error by Lacroix 🤬"
Positive 8.5%
Neutral 30.2%
Negative 61.2%
Right, so here's the thing about Newcastle fans after that Crystal Palace penalty call — three quarters of them stayed remarkably level-headed, almost impressed by the sheer audacity of what they'd just witnessed, but the moment you dug into the posts, you found genuine fury simmering underneath because they weren't actually angry at the dive itself, they were furious at the referee for buying it, and even more furious at themselves for knowing it wouldn't matter because they'd been playing poorly all season anyway. What made it worse was the split: some supporters could appreciate the craft, the quick thinking, the cold calculation of a player getting away with it, whilst others just saw it as the final straw in a growing list of officiating decisions that felt designed specifically to punish Newcastle, and that frustration wasn't really about one moment — it was about everything collapsing at once.
Neutral
75.0%
"Pulled back and falls forward.
Clever stuff. Well done."
Annoyance
14.1%
"Man’s flying"
Anger
10.9%
"God i hate refs, that was never a pen.
Doesnt help we play shit every game along side it, but i hate watching football currently."
Positive 43.4%
Neutral 36.4%
Negative 20.2%
Here's the thing—Newcastle fans were genuinely impressed by Osula's performance despite the goalless result, with nearly three-quarters of the conversation staying level-headed and analytical rather than reactive. What got them excited wasn't just the player himself, but the *football* he was involved in—they were raving about the combination play on the right flank, the quick one-touch passing, and most importantly, that assist that should've been a goal. It's that rare moment where fans appreciate the quality of play and individual brilliance even when the scoreline doesn't reflect it, which tells you everything about how much Osula impressed at the Etihad.
Neutral
67.3%
"Get in Osula!!! Great improv! "
Admiration
26.9%
"Get in Osula!!! Great improv! "
Amusement
5.8%
"Osula is one of the funniest players ever, love him "
Positive 6.2%
Neutral 34.1%
Negative 59.7%
Here's the thing — Newcastle's fanbase was overwhelmingly calm about Gordon and Barnes, with 78 per cent keeping their cool, but that surface-level composure masks a real undercurrent of frustration bubbling beneath the surface. The 16 per cent expressing annoyance weren't angry at the quality of play itself; they were furious at the *intensity*, the effort, the feeling that these players simply weren't giving enough of a damn when it mattered most. And then you've got that 7 per cent absolutely seething, convinced Gordon had mentally checked out entirely — which tells you everything about how Newcastle's standards have shifted this season, because when your fanbase is questioning effort over ability, you've got a deeper problem on your hands.
Neutral
77.7%
"Lovely pass to Strand Larson from Gordon to setup the corner. "
Annoyance
15.5%
"Fuck Gordon man, he doesn’t give a fuck "
Anger
6.8%
"Fuck Gordon man, he doesn’t give a fuck "
Positive 14.8%
Neutral 28.7%
Negative 56.6%
Here's the thing — Crystal Palace's collapse in this fixture shouldn't have been funny, but the fanbase found themselves laughing through the pain because this wasn't shock anymore, it was pure inevitability. Nearly two-fifths of supporters had gone completely numb to it, whilst more than a third were finding dark humour in the familiar script unfolding before them, and that tells you everything about a season where disappointment stopped stinging and started feeling like a punchline. The anger was there, sure, but it was buried beneath resignation and gallows comedy — the kind of laughter that comes when you've seen the same film so many times you're already mouthing along to the dialogue.
Amusement
35.6%
"Hahaha very good"
Anger
23.0%
"Fucking pathetic jesus Christ "
Positive 23.9%
Neutral 24.8%
Negative 51.3%
Both sets of fans are absolutely seething about the exact same problem: they take the lead, sit back, invite pressure, and then get pegged back—and here is the thing, it happens week after week after week, which is turning frustration into something darker. The minority who are happy about securing three points can see a win is a win, but the overwhelming consensus from Palace and Newcastle supporters is one of exasperation—not just because they threw away chances to kill the game, but because the tactical pattern has become so predictable and so repetitive that fans feel like they're watching the same catastrophe unfold on loop.
Neutral
50.0%
"Soon as we scored first I knew we were fucked"
Disappointment
30.6%
"We are losing this. Exactly the same every fucking game. "Let sit back on this 1-0 lead guys". They score and equalize, we try to attack again and the"
Approval
19.4%
"Should've won by 3 easily! Lovely win"
Positive 11.3%
Neutral 45.3%
Negative 43.4%
Crystal Palace fans are caught in that brutal limbo where beating top-six sides feels meaningless because they're still nowhere near the European places, and the frustration is real—they've squandered enough winning positions this season that there's this creeping sense of resignation, a "we are what our league position says we are" attitude mixed with dark humour about how a squad capable of taking points off Manchester United and Chelsea somehow finds itself battling mediocrity. What's got them genuinely curious, though, is whether Palace can even scrape together a run against sides they should be competitive with, because right now the narrative isn't "we're too good for this league," it's "we're exactly where we deserve to be," and that's the kind of cold, honest assessment that shows you've stopped making excuses and started facing facts.
Neutral
57.8%
"We look like a top tier Championship squad with this lineup"
Curiosity
23.4%
"It’s shocking that all the teams below us in the league now are fighting a relegation battle. "
Disappointment
18.8%
"My fucking God how sick I am to lose from a winning position"
Positive 8.7%
Neutral 47.1%
Negative 44.2%
Right, so Newcastle fans are keeping it remarkably composed after getting absolutely done by Palace — we're talking nearly 80 per cent neutral sentiment here — but there's a simmering frustration underneath because, and this is what really stings, Palace looked utterly disinterested for the first hour, made their changes, and still picked them apart like they were a training ground exercise. The fear crawling through the fanbase isn't just about one loss; it's the creeping realisation that any momentum Newcastle might've built is collapsing, and if they can't beat a half-arsed Crystal Palace side, the whole season's narrative just shifted in a matter of 90 minutes.
Neutral
79.2%
"Palace look much better after the subs. "
Disappointment
11.1%
"Palace visibly couldn’t give a shit for the first 65 minutes or so and we still lost. Really puts to bed any hopes that we’re randomly going to go on "
Joy
9.7%
"glad to see crystal palace win against new castle you dont see this everyday"
Positive 9.6%
Neutral 35.1%
Negative 55.3%
Crystal Palace fans were absolutely seething after their manager waited until the damage was done before finally making substitutions, with supporters hammering him on social media for closing the stable door after the horse had bolted. The frustration wasn't just about the late changes themselves — it was the predictability of it, the sense that everybody in the stadium saw the problem coming but the gaffer refused to act until they'd already conceded. There's a particular sting to that kind of tactical inertia, and the fanbase made it clear they felt utterly let down by the refusal to make proactive decisions when it actually mattered.
Neutral
78.6%
"Subs? A cracking idea. About 15 mins ago"
Anger
11.4%
"Knew that was coming and we deserve it. We've been dogshit. The system is dogshit.
And we've made no changes because our manager doesn't fucking lik"
Positive 18.6%
Neutral 36.0%
Negative 45.3%
Newcastle fans weren't angry—they were baffled, and that might be worse, because what they witnessed was so absurd it tipped into black comedy: Eddie Howe bringing on Wissa with literally seconds remaining in a match where Newcastle were already dead in the water. The sarcasm was sharp and relentless, with supporters pointing out the contradiction between the club's summer investment in Wissa as a supposed season-saver and the reality of a manager apparently using him as a substitute for a substitute, in a tactical decision that made absolutely no football sense whatsoever.
Neutral
80.4%
"Elanga and Wissa on for 18 seconds. Nice one Eddie."
Amusement
10.7%
"Only idiots repeat what the journalists say. Remember when Wissa was meant to save our season despite all our issues stemming from the build up?"
Curiosity
8.9%
"Osula miles better than Wissa/Wolte so far. Let’s see if he has the juice to last 70+ mins "
Positive 56.8%
Neutral 18.5%
Negative 24.7%
Crystal Palace's dramatic late victory had the fanbase absolutely euphoric, with over half the supporters expressing genuine admiration for what they'd witnessed — and it was the *quality* of the football that drove this reaction, not just the result itself. The build-up play leading to the winning goal was getting serious praise in the chat, with fans dissecting the movement and positioning like they'd just watched a masterclass, which tells you everything you need to know about how clinical Palace were in that final moment. With only eight percent registering anger, this was one of those rare moments where even neutrals had to respect the execution, and that's precisely why the conversation stayed overwhelmingly positive rather than descending into the usual post-match toxicity.
Admiration
53.2%
"Greatest game everrrrr! So happy I got to watch it in the director box"
Neutral
38.7%
"Very good goal and build up there. "
Anger
8.1%
"What a shit goal lmfao "
Positive 33.8%
Neutral 46.8%
Negative 19.5%
Here's the thing: Crystal Palace fans weren't going absolutely mental after that win, but they were genuinely impressed, and that matters. Mateta's second-half masterclass earned him the "Mr Dependable" label from supporters who'd finally seen their team show real tactical depth—not just starting eleven quality, but actual impact from the bench. The respect was earned, measured, and real: fans were celebrating a complete performance and a player they could actually rely on, rather than getting swept up in some flash-in-the-pan moment.
Neutral
76.7%
"@CPFC Great game and exciting result. I said it strong lineup and depth on the bench. Mr Dependable and Reliable Mateta get the double to secure the m"
Admiration
15.0%
"Loving the Mateta celebration and crowd chant ❤❤❤"
Love
8.3%
"Loving the Mateta celebration and crowd chant ❤❤❤"
Positive 6.8%
Neutral 40.5%
Negative 52.7%
Newcastle fans weren't just disappointed after losing to Crystal Palace — they were furious at what they saw as a complete waste of preparation time, with nearly three-quarters of the conversation staying eerily measured whilst the rest erupted into sarcasm about those two weeks of training that apparently counted for absolutely nothing. The real sting wasn't just the result itself; it was the betrayal of expectation, the sense that a lengthy break should've fixed something fundamental, yet here they were, watching the same tired performance unfold, which is why you heard that bitter edge creeping into the discourse — fans weren't angry, they were insulted.
Neutral
70.9%
"Let's see how good that training has been"
Annoyance
16.4%
"A two-week break to reconvene and we lose to the same fucking shit. "
Disappointment
12.7%
"A two-week break to reconvene and we lose to the same fucking shit. "
Positive 33.3%
Neutral 22.2%
Negative 44.4%
Right, so here's the thing about Newcastle fans this week — they're absolutely torn between genuine admiration for this striker's raw ability and genuine frustration at his inconsistency, and it's creating this weird tension where nobody can quite decide if they're watching world-class talent or someone who's only switching on when he fancies it. You've got supporters genuinely comparing him to elite company — we're talking Messi comparisons — but that admiration is getting undercut by the disappointment that he's not delivering that level week in, week out, and that's what's got the fanbase split down the middle.
Neutral
57.9%
"He is the second best player I have ever seen in person. After Messi.
Genuinely his talent on the ball has him in the same class as the likes of the"
Admiration
24.6%
"Unbelievably good…when he wanted to be. "
Disappointment
17.5%
"He's the worst striker I've seen put on a Newcastle shirt since Riviere "
Positive 6.2%
Neutral 35.9%
Negative 57.8%
Palace fans walked away from Newcastle absolutely fuming at their own incompetence, not the result — because here's the thing, they'd finally glimpsed what they're actually capable of when they move the ball with purpose, and then promptly forgot how to do it again. The anger wasn't really about the draw itself; it was the brutal realisation that they've got the quality somewhere in there, buried under months of ponderous, static football, but nobody seems able to unlock it consistently. Every misplaced pass, every wasted set-piece, every cross that went nowhere — it all felt like watching a team sabotage themselves, and that's what got under the skin more than anything Newcastle threw at them.
Neutral
78.0%
"We've been trying this quick passing all game. It finally worked. Who knew playing quick football can catch teams out?!"
Anger
14.0%
"Jesus fucking Christ we cannot pass or cross or shoot the ball "
Disappointment
8.0%
"the way we fuck up the simplest of passes in key positions. It’s just so pathetic"
Positive 46.0%
Neutral 33.3%
Negative 20.6%
So here's the thing — when Crystal Palace and Newcastle served up this absolute feast of a match at Selhurst Park in gameweek thirty-two, fans weren't going mental in the way you'd expect, but they were absolutely locked in on one specific detail: the camera work was borderline genius. Two-thirds of the conversation stayed measured and analytical, but that remaining third who did get animated? They weren't celebrating goals or drama — they were celebrating the cinematography itself, the angles, the framing, calling it perhaps the best visual presentation they'd seen all season in the Premier League. It's a fascinating moment because it reveals something about modern football discourse: sometimes the match itself becomes secondary to how it's presented to you.
Neutral
66.7%
"Great noise that. Great noise"
Approval
16.7%
"Great noise that. Great noise"
Excitement
16.7%
"A successful afternoon at Selhurst 🤩 https://t.co/BWw00JYoAR"
Positive 54.2%
Neutral 30.5%
Negative 15.3%
So here's what happened at Selhurst Park — Newcastle's young talent Lewis Miley put in a display that absolutely split the fanbase down the middle, and we're talking a proper civil war in those comments sections. You've got one camp genuinely buzzing about what they saw from the lad, talking about his quality and his return to action, but then you've got another group so wound up about the result and the performance that they're venting all their frustration at the manager and the coaching staff instead. The numbers tell you everything: neutral reactions dominating at fifty-four percent, sure, but that thirty-three percent admiration for Miley himself is fighting for space with real, genuine disappointment at how it all played out — and that's the tension right there.
Neutral
54.2%
"@NUFC Well done LEWIS MILEY AND OSULA!!!!!!!!!!!!"
Admiration
33.3%
"Miley is beautiful. So good. "
Disappointment
12.5%
"@NUFC Het this amateurish cunt out and his tits of an Assistant and coaches bunch of amateurish clowns same shite same reactionary subs why's has Mile"
Positive 5.1%
Neutral 39.0%
Negative 55.9%
So here's the thing — Crystal Palace versus Newcastle in Matchweek 32 was supposed to be a Premier League spectacle, but instead it delivered something so utterly forgettable that fans genuinely couldn't believe they'd wasted two hours of their lives watching it. The match was tactically nervy, defensively cautious, and about as entertaining as watching paint dry on a terrible camera angle, which is exactly why the fanbase split almost evenly between those who'd resigned themselves to the reality of modern football and those absolutely seething at the lack of quality on display. What really stung wasn't just the drab football itself — it was the sense that this is what we're paying good money to watch these days, with one fan sarcastically suggesting the Premier League should use the footage in their next TV rights negotiation as a warning to potential broadcasters.
Neutral
64.3%
"Great stuff this. PL at its finest.
They should include this in the showreel when negotiating the next set of telly rights."
Annoyance
19.0%
"This is borderline unwatchable. A good game would at least balance out the ugly pitch, ugly camera angle and ugly kit. But no. Insipid blandness it is"
Disappointment
16.7%
"This is borderline unwatchable. A good game would at least balance out the ugly pitch, ugly camera angle and ugly kit. But no. Insipid blandness it is"
Positive 36.7%
Neutral 36.7%
Negative 26.5%
Here's the thing: when Palace nicked that late winner against Newcastle in Matchday 32, the overriding reaction wasn't rage or despair — it was begrudging respect, with over half the fanbase staying level-headed about what they'd witnessed. Yes, there was anger bubbling underneath for a quarter of supporters who'd watched their side surrender late, but the dominant mood was admiration, particularly for Ramsdale's performance in keeping Newcastle in it for so long — fans kept hammering home that he'd been "excellent," almost like they needed to acknowledge a goalkeeper doing his job brilliantly even in defeat. That's the brutal complexity of football: you can lose a match and still walk away impressed by your own player's heroics, which is exactly what happened here.
Neutral
56.4%
"Ramsdale! Excellent!"
Admiration
25.6%
"Ramsdale! Excellent!"
Anger
17.9%
"fuck every single one of them out there minus ramsdale"
Positive 12.5%
Neutral 45.8%
Negative 41.7%
Newcastle fans have hit a wall of grim acceptance after watching their £200 million summer recruitment strategy implode in a draw they should've won—and here's the thing, the rage isn't even sharp anymore, it's settled into something colder: the realisation that Eddie Howe's bold bench gamble has actively crippled them. You've got experienced players like Ty gathering dust on the sidelines whilst the team struggles, and when your marquee striker departs for Liverpool without adequate replacement, suddenly that massive investment looks less like ambition and more like a monument to poor planning.
Neutral
74.3%
"Ty is probably the most underrated player in the league. Better than Hall and more experienced than O'Reilly he should be nailed on for the squad but "
Annoyance
14.3%
"This season was ruined the second our star striker downed tools and pissed off to Liverpool and our failure to replace him spunking 120m on bench fodd"
Disappointment
11.4%
"Ty is probably the most underrated player in the league. Better than Hall and more experienced than O'Reilly he should be nailed on for the squad but "
Positive 2.2%
Neutral 45.7%
Negative 52.2%
Right, so here's the thing — Munoz got away with murder out there, and Crystal Palace fans were absolutely seething that Madley let him off the hook. The anger wasn't just simmering frustration either; it was the accumulated rage of watching repeated fouls go unpunished throughout the entire match, which made fans question whether the referee was simply incompetent or had lost control of the game completely. What made it worse was that most fans recognised this as yet another example of the Premier League's broader refereeing inconsistency — one they felt they'd seen far too many times before.
Neutral
76.9%
"All game that Munoz cunt has fouled us and played dirty. Ref is a moron who loves to lick whistles"
Annoyance
12.8%
"Fuck me munoz is dirty like "
Anger
10.3%
"Fuck me munoz is dirty like "
Positive 6.8%
Neutral 29.5%
Negative 63.6%
Newcastle fans have turned on Aurelien Botman after a soft penalty conceded against Crystal Palace, and here is the thing — the anger is real, but it is complicated. Yes, the French defender made a reckless challenge that handed Palace a lifeline they didn't deserve, and the fans are rightfully frustrated because this keeps happening with him and Sven Thiaw. But what is driving the real annoyance is the predictability of it all: Botman has become a liability for these defensive brainfarts, and Newcastle know they cannot keep winning despite their centre-backs actively costing them points.
Neutral
63.3%
"Ooooo my god Botman is officially BATMAN with his mask"
Annoyance
20.0%
"That's so fucking soft, but so predictable. Botman and Thiaw are fucking horrendous for howlers."
Anger
16.7%
"That's so fucking soft, but so predictable. Botman and Thiaw are fucking horrendous for howlers."
Positive 14.3%
Neutral 40.5%
Negative 45.2%
Right, so Newcastle fans are sat on the fence about Livramento after this one — and the numbers prove it, because nearly four in five of them are just staying neutral, analysing what went wrong rather than launching a full witch-hunt. But here's the tension: there's this vocal minority prepared to stick their neck out and say Livramento's positioning is genuinely poor, especially when it matters most, whilst the other half of that minority are quick to remind everyone that he's still a game-changer when he's fit and focused — which is basically the football equivalent of saying he's brilliant when he plays well, cheers for that. The difference is Hall's getting the "warrior" treatment no matter what, but Tino's still having to prove he can maintain that intensity, because one defensive brain-fart and suddenly the scrutiny comes out in force.
Neutral
81.2%
"We are such a better team when we have Tino and Hall on the field. Total game changers "
Disapproval
9.4%
"I’ll continue to be downvoted but I’ll continue to say it, Tino Livramento can’t defend his back post. He’s a really poor right back."
Admiration
9.4%
"We are such a better team when we have Tino and Hall on the field. Total game changers "
Positive 4.8%
Neutral 28.6%
Negative 66.7%
Crystal Palace fans are hitting a wall of despair as Matchweek 32 rolls round, and here is the thing — they are not angry in the way you might expect from a fanbase demanding change. Instead, the overwhelming reaction is resignation, a weary acceptance that this is just what being a Palace supporter means: watching the same mediocre cycle spin out year after year. The anger that does exist is almost exhausted, buried under a layer of numbness so thick that some fans can barely summon the energy to care whether the season ends or not — and that apathy, that hollow "always is" refrain echoing through the fanbase, might be the most telling sign of all.
Neutral
58.3%
"Can't wait for the season to end "
Approval
20.8%
"Always is"
Anger
20.8%
"I fucking hate this team "
Positive 13.9%
Neutral 27.8%
Negative 58.3%
Here is the thing — when Palace and Newcastle locked eyes with Spurs at Matchweek 32, the overwhelming feeling wasn't anger or hope, it was relief, pure schadenfreude, because both sides realised that watching Tottenham implode was far more valuable than any three points they could nick off each other. The amusement was real, the gallows humour unmistakable — these fans knew their own teams were barely scraping by, but as long as Spurs kept being the season's catastrophe, the heat was off them, and that's the brutal football calculus right there. But here's where it gets interesting: beneath the jokes was genuine strategic tension, because some supporters understood that Spurs actually needed to *win* to keep the pressure away from their own relegation scrap, creating this twisted scenario where you're almost rooting for the team you despise.
Neutral
59.1%
"More beneficial for us for spurs to win tbh"
Amusement
22.7%
"Good things Spurs has all the attention, otherwise we'd be this seasons joke"
Desire
18.2%
"Would love to see a super league breakaway team in the championship"
Positive 2.9%
Neutral 22.9%
Negative 74.3%
Newcastle fans weren't actually that furious about losing this one — they were almost grimly unsurprised, which somehow stings worse. The real anger wasn't directed at the penalty call itself, but at their manager's seeming inability to address a glaring, season-long pattern of defensive lapses and poor decision-making, with supporters essentially saying: "This isn't a one-off, this is who we are right now." There was a dark comedy to the whole thing, a resignation that epitomised their campaign — the blueprint for failure had been drawn up weeks ago, and here it was being executed once again.
Neutral
73.1%
"@NUFC That was the blueprint NUFC performance if I’ve ever seen one.
Nothing ‘uncharacteristic’ about that."
Amusement
15.4%
"It's absolutely characteristic. Stats don't lie."
Curiosity
11.5%
"It's absolutely characteristic. Stats don't lie."
Positive 23.5%
Neutral 26.5%
Negative 50.0%
Newcastle fans are drowning in sarcasm after that late collapse against Crystal Palace, and you can almost hear the resigned exhaustion through their posts. They're trapped in this bizarre emotional limbo where the neutrality is so thick it wraps around genuine despair—repeating "everything is fine" like a mantra that's completely fallen apart, because deep down they know another late goal has just torched their top-four hopes. The approval you're seeing? That's the gallows humour of a fanbase that's watched this film before, and they're done pretending it has a happy ending.
Neutral
80.0%
"It's fine. Everything is fine. "
Approval
12.0%
"Yep, smooth sailing from here on out. "
Sadness
8.0%
"… fuckin tragic we are back to this "
Positive 58.8%
Neutral 29.4%
Negative 11.8%
Crystal Palace fans were absolutely buzzing after this one, but here's the thing — most weren't getting properly sentimental about their club identity or mascot heritage. No, the real story is that 58 percent of the conversation stayed neutral and measured, with fans keeping it simple: they'd seen a decent performance and a positive result, and that was enough. The admiration and approval that did creep in — roughly 42 percent combined — was all about the immediate turnaround on the pitch, the momentum, the "UP THE PALACE" energy of a team doing the business, rather than any deeper club mythology stuff. Classic football fans, really: they'll celebrate who you are when you're winning, but what they're actually excited about is what you just did.
Neutral
58.3%
"@CPFC Good win palace. #eagles #cpfc #boom"
Admiration
25.0%
"@CPFC Good win palace. #eagles #cpfc #boom"
Approval
16.7%
"@CPFC Good win palace. #eagles #cpfc #boom"
Positive 6.2%
Neutral 31.2%
Negative 62.5%
Right, here's the thing: after that defeat to Newcastle in Matchweek 32, Crystal Palace's fanbase fractured spectacularly—and the real fury wasn't directed at the opposition, it was aimed inward at their own so-called "happy clappers," those supporters willing to accept mediocrity without complaint. The toxicity cut deep because losing alongside passive acceptance of underperformance is basically a recipe for sustained frustration, and you could feel the desperation in those posts, the sense that some fans had finally had enough of what they saw as complicit cheerleading whilst the club drifted. But here's where it gets interesting: that emotional breakdown tells you most Palace supporters stayed measured about it—seventy per cent neutral—which suggests this wasn't a full-blown mutiny, just a sharp and very public disappointment that their own fanbase seemed to be enabling drift rather than demanding better.
Neutral
70.0%
"@NUFC Happy clappers will be delighted with that one"
Joy
15.0%
"@NUFC Happy clappers will be delighted with that one"
Annoyance
15.0%
"@NUFC Spineless stupid fucking cunt why is there away fans clapping him in the fucking stands for you know how embarrassing that is? We had 3 weeks of"
Positive 0.0%
Neutral 40.6%
Negative 59.4%
So here's the thing — Newcastle fans were absolutely seething after Joelinton picked up a yellow card that could cost them in the run-in, and their reactions ranged from bewildered fury to pitch-black humour about his overall performance. Most supporters stayed measured about it, but the ones who weren't held nothing back, questioning both the decision and Joelinton's contribution to the match itself, with some already dreading the prospect of facing their next two games without their number nine available. It's that perfect storm of frustration — a potentially match-deciding card handed to a player who, in their eyes, hadn't exactly earned the benefit of the doubt with his display.
Neutral
75.0%
"Joe, mate, what the fuck was that?! "
Anger
12.5%
"Joe, mate, what the fuck was that?! "
Amusement
12.5%
"Done it again, Joe can’t bring the man down because he has a yellow and the defence has switched off. Mint"
Newcastle supporters are locked in a heated debate about one of their strikers' quality and whether he's been given sufficient opportunity to prove himself, with some arguing he's been dire whenever he's played whilst others contend he's never received proper support or a genuine run in the team. The discussion reveals a fractured fanbase unable to agree on whether the player is simply not good enough or a victim of circumstance and poor service.
The Complete Write-Off
These fans believe Joelinton is fundamentally unsuited to Premier League football and has proven nothing but disappointment in a Newcastle shirt, making his continued presence untenable.
disappointment
Joelinton
Joe Willock
"He's the worst striker I've seen put on a Newcastle shirt since Riviere "
"Messed around? He’s been given chances and stank the gaff out every single time. Hes awful "
The Talent Believers
This camp argues Joelinton possesses elite technical ability that occasionally surfaces, but inconsistency and mentality issues prevent him from delivering the performances his talent suggests he should.
admiration
Nathaniel Clyne
Borna Sosa
Daniel Muñoz
"Unbelievably good…when he wanted to be. "
"He is the second best player I have ever seen in person. After Messi.
Genuinely his talent on the ball has him in the same class as the likes of the greatest of all time.
He is"
The Measured Realists
These supporters acknowledge Joelinton had a genuine purple patch earlier in the season but recognise the broader truth: he's reverted to being a liability and should be moved on.
neutral
Joelinton
Joe Willock
"He just had his purple patch like miggy, we should have sold then. He's been shite all season"
"I'm actually so done with him. No attacking nuance, loose passes, can't hold it up. Time to move on"
Crystal Palace fans are celebrating Jean-Philippe Mateta's dramatic stoppage-time penalty to secure a 2-1 comeback victory over Newcastle, though the discussion reveals sharp disagreement about whether the referee got the call right and whether Palace's defence deserved such fortune. The largely positive sentiment masks underlying tension, with supporters divided on whether they earned the win through character or simply benefited from a controversial decision.
It's All About The Theatre
Nearly three-fifths of fans are absolutely mesmerised by what they've witnessed — they're celebrating the sheer spectacle and quality of the buildup, convinced this is the kind of moment that defines seasons.
admiration
Jacob Murphy
Harvey Barnes
"Greatest game everrrrr! So happy I got to watch it in the director box"
"Build up play for the goal was wonderful. "
The Goal Was Absolutely Dodgy
A quarter of the fanbase isn't buying the narrative at all, furious that what they see as a fundamentally broken piece of play has somehow counted, and they're not holding back about it.
anger
Jacob Murphy
Harvey Barnes
Yoane Wissa
"What a shit goal lmfao "
"That was a fucking atrocious attack"
You're Missing What Actually Happened Here
A smaller but vocal contingent are pushing back against the narrative itself, insisting that the real story — the goalkeeper's exceptional defensive actions — is being completely drowned out by the controversy.
neutral
Jacob Murphy
Harvey Barnes
"I can't believe this is real, he makes two good quick saves and your take is to slag him for it."
"Second save is absolutely ridiculous "
Fans are split on goalkeeper Aaron Ramsdale's performance in Crystal Palace's controversial 2-1 comeback victory over Newcastle, with some defending his effort despite the goals whilst others criticise his distribution and positioning on the decisive penalty. The discussion centres on whether the defending or Ramsdale himself bears responsibility for the late collapse.
Ramsdale Deserves The Credit
These fans are giving the goalkeeper genuine praise for a moment of quality when everything else around him fell apart.
admiration
Kieran Trippier
Nick Pope
"Ramsdale! Excellent!"
"Excellent from Ramsdale."
Chaos And Mixed Reactions
This group is processing the raw madness of the occasion — caught between shock at Ramsdale's involvement and frustration at his long-ball tendencies that sometimes haunt them.
neutral
Kieran Trippier
Nick Pope
"fucking hell Ramsdale, alright alright I'm awake now"
"Wish Ramsdale would stop these crap long kicks "
Everyone Failed Except Him
Pure rage at the collective collapse, but with one exception: they're singling out Ramsdale as the only player who actually showed up when it mattered.
anger
Kieran Trippier
Nick Pope
Dan Burn
"fuck every single one of them out there minus ramsdale"
"FUCKING HELL RAMSDALE MAN"
Supporters from both sides are locked in frustration over their teams' inability to convert dominance into goals, with fans pointing to poor finishing and weak shot quality despite controlling periods of play. The neutral sentiment reflects a split between those who saw glimpses of competence and those who view it as another disappointing, characteristically blunt performance from a side lacking attacking conviction.
The Eternal Cycle of Collapse
These fans believe the team has a structural, repeat pattern of throwing away leads through poor defending and conservative tactics, and they're exhausted by watching it happen week after week.
disappointment
Jacob Murphy
Harvey Barnes
Yoane Wissa
"We are losing this. Exactly the same every fucking game. "Let sit back on this 1-0 lead guys". They score and equalize, we try to attack again and they score on the counter. No ene"
"Every game we go up . We don't defend and we end up losing... Same shit different week fucking sick of it "
Seen It All Before Realists
This camp watches the match unfold and recognises the familiar script unfolding — they're not surprised by the outcome because this is simply who the team is right now.
"At half time, or even going back to our goal, can anyone put their hand on heart and say they expected us to win and we're surprised we didn't ? Even before the ko"
"Yeah, same as we have been all season."
Prophets of the Inevitable
These fans have a fatalistic acceptance that whenever they take the lead, disaster follows; they predict their own downfall the moment they go ahead and almost find grim humour in being right.
neutral
Jacob Murphy
Harvey Barnes
"Soon as we scored first I knew we were fucked"
"Hahahaha standard fucking useless second half performance "
The Delusional Minority
A smaller pocket of supporters who watched the exact same match but left genuinely pleased, believing they dominated and could've won by more — utterly disconnected from the broader fanbase's reality.
approval
Jacob Murphy
Harvey Barnes
"Should've won by 3 easily! Lovely win"
"Could have had 4 real easy. Pretty good match all things considered, very happy with the 3!"
Crystal Palace and Newcastle supporters aren't discussing the dramatic 2-1 finish at Selhurst — they're collectively losing their minds over the highlight thumbnail itself, with fans praising it as one of the best they've ever seen, particularly the cinematography of Mateta's winning penalty kick moment. The imagery has transcended the match itself, with viewers calling it a movie poster-worthy shot that deserves recognition for the photographer's work.
Pure Euphoria, No Questions
These fans are just soaking in the moment—they don't need analysis, they need catharsis, and that thumbnail delivered it in spades.
approval
excitement
"Great noise that. Great noise"
"You simply love to see it."
The Aura's Undeniable, Mate
This lot recognises something genuinely special happened, and they're impressed by the sheer visual power of what unfolded before them.
"Felt the aura from three videos away 💥 what a thumbnail"
"was about to mention the thumbnail till i saweveryone else noticed it what a shot haha"
The Stadium's Let Us Down
They're more bothered about Selhurst Park's technical incompetence than the match itself—the camera angle and pitch layout have wound them up something proper.
neutral
"I hate Selhurst Park for this camera angle."
"I'm triggered by the fact the halfway line doesn't go in between both dugouts. I hate this stadium."
Unsure If It Was Right
This group's caught between admiration and doubt, sensing the moment was stunning but wrestling with whether what actually happened holds up to scrutiny.
"Felt the aura from three videos away 💥 what a thumbnail"
"was about to mention the thumbnail till i saweveryone else noticed it what a shot haha"
Selhurst Park Ruins Everything
These supporters are fuming—not at the players or the play, but at the ground itself, which they reckon consistently sabotages the viewing experience and winds them up relentlessly.
"I hate games at Selhurst with a passion. Always the same."
"This might be the worst camera angle I’ve ever seen "
Newcastle supporters are split on youngster Lewis Miley's performance in the 2-1 defeat to Crystal Palace, with some praising him as a rare bright spark whilst others criticise his defensive positioning and argue he should have been substituted earlier. The broader frustration centres on tactical issues and manager Eddie Howe's in-game decision-making, with fans questioning why tired players like Murphy remained on the pitch when fresher options were available.
Miley's The Answer
These fans are convinced Miley's return is exactly what Newcastle needed, seeing his performance as a sign of better things to come regardless of the Palace result.
admiration
Joelinton
Joe Willock
"Miley is beautiful. So good. "
"I love Miley, so glad he’s back. "
Mixed Bag Performance
This camp acknowledges Miley had an off day alongside other struggling players, offering balanced criticism that separates the player's potential from today's underwhelming display.
neutral
Joelinton
Joe Willock
"Tino was totally off it today. I also don't think Miley should have started, I love the kid but he uncharacteristically gave the ball away several times.
It's depressing how shit "
"Dreadful from Miley there"
Same Old Newcastle Blues
Cynical observers who've seen this story play out too many times before, questioning why they'd expect anything different from another frustrating draw that defines the club's season.
"I missed the last 5 mins and only just found out it didnt end in a draw. Honestly though why expect any different than usual.
Miley for all the potential and greatness so far sho"
"Feel like Miley absolutely has been"
Unfinished Business Analysis
Fans caught between moments of the match, trying to piece together what actually happened whilst forming tentative opinions about key players in the chaos.
"I missed the last 5 mins and only just found out it didnt end in a draw. Honestly though why expect any different than usual.
Miley for all the potential and greatness so far sho"
"Feel like Miley absolutely has been"
Enough Is Enough Fury
The fed-up faction demanding wholesale changes at every level, convinced that Miley, the coaching staff, and the entire setup are fundamentally broken and beyond redemption.
disappointment
Joelinton
Joe Willock
Sandro Tonali
"@NUFC Het this amateurish cunt out and his tits of an Assistant and coaches bunch of amateurish clowns same shite same reactionary subs why's has Miley lasted the while game he's b"
"@NUFC Miley and Livramento are absolutely useless"
Crystal Palace supporters are celebrating a rollercoaster 2-1 comeback victory, with Jean-Philippe Mateta scoring twice in quick succession—including a penalty deep into injury time—to turn the match on its head after Newcastle had taken the lead early on. The fanbase's reactions swing wildly between euphoria at the dramatic turnaround and lingering frustration at how poorly Palace performed for large stretches, creating a decidedly mixed mood despite the three points.
Mitchell's Redemption Arc
These fans believe the late winner proves Palace have finally found a genuine game-changer, and they're willing to give full credit to the manager and players who delivered when it mattered.
approval
"@CPFC I’m so grateful we have Mitchell."
"@CPFC Congratulations,nice kick"
We're Still A Mess
This crowd accepts the three points but refuses to pretend the journey there was anything other than embarrassing, viewing the win as fortunate damage control rather than genuine progress.
neutral
"@CPFC God we’ve been awful in the Premier League this season haha"
"@CPFC Fucking rubbish"
Just Vibes And Relief
These fans are caught between wanting to celebrate the result and struggling to process a performance that was clearly far from convincing, so they're expressing mixed emotions through humour and relief.
"@stevecharlton145😂👍🔴⚪️🔴⚪️🔴⚪️🔴"
"Thank you JP 🔴🔵🦅"
Defensive Collapse Merchants
Furious with individual errors and tactical breakdowns, this group sees the win as masking systemic problems that will come back to haunt Palace when the margins get tighter.
anger
"@CPFC Terrible defensive error by Lacroix 🤬"
"@CPFC Just another crap performance after a Thursday game. No surprise."
Magic Moment Eclipses Everything
These supporters are so caught up in the drama of the late goal that they're temporarily suspending judgment on the wider performance, choosing to savour the emotional high instead.
"@stevecharlton145😂👍🔴⚪️🔴⚪️🔴⚪️🔴"
"Thank you JP 🔴🔵🦅"
Newcastle supporters are devastated after conceding a dramatic 90+4 penalty to lose 2-1 at Crystal Palace, with fans expressing resignation that the club's recent progress has collapsed and they're reverting to old patterns of failure. The mood is one of hopelessness rather than anger — many appear to have emotionally checked out, viewing this result as confirmation that significant change is needed at the club.
The Cycle Never Breaks
These fans see Newcastle's late collapse as proof that heartbreak is hardwired into the club's DNA, and they're devastated because they thought this era was finally different.
sadness
"… fuckin tragic we are back to this "
"I hate that it’s gone this way, it’s gonna end toxic. "
Just Another Plot Twist
These fans are documenting what happened with detached curiosity, treating the dramatic reversal as just the latest chapter in Newcastle's chaotic story rather than a defining moment.
neutral
"We're so back
https://preview.redd.it/kkips7rifrug1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0eca093426051495b4cdf360ea24f8d6a98417d6"
"We are so back"
The Comeback's Already Written
These fans are convinced the setback is temporary and that Newcastle's trajectory is so strong that this loss is merely a speed bump on the way to sustained success.
approval
"Best 3 weeks of my life, and now we're back here"
"Yep, smooth sailing from here on out. "
Newcastle supporters are divided over William Osula's display against Crystal Palace, with some praising his hold-up play and first-half contribution whilst others criticise his ineffectiveness and question whether he should start ahead of the club's expensive attacking options. The broader frustration centres on Newcastle losing control after the break and failing to build on their early-game momentum.
Osula's Finally Arrived
This lot are convinced the lad showed genuine quality with his movement and combination play, celebrating what they reckon is a proper breakthrough moment for the young striker.
admiration
amusement
Joelinton
Joe Willock
Sandro Tonali
"Get in Osula!!! Great improv! "
"The combination play on the right was great, all feet to feet and quick. Awesome cross and Osula gets his rewards! Aside from losing it in the middle from Ramsdale, he’s been goo"
Right, What Actually Happened
These fans are calling out the cold, hard reality — Osula went missing when it mattered and the service was frankly abysmal, so let's stop pretending this was anything special.
neutral
Jacob Murphy
Harvey Barnes
"Anyone with half a head could see that coming. Osula ineffective last 15 minutes and Miley blowing out of his arse so leave them both on until we concede. "
" That was not a good challenge by Osula lol"
He's Trying But We're Failing Him
This camp reckons Osula gets unfairly hammered because Newcastle's midfield isn't giving him the ammunition he needs to prove himself, so the real problem sits elsewhere on the pitch.
Jacob Murphy
Harvey Barnes
"Osula really isn’t good enough…"
"I thought Osula was strong at holding it up early on. Just had fuck all support and service"
Crystal Palace supporters are discussing the club's rich heritage dating back to 1861 and celebrating their iconic eagle mascot, with some playful banter about Newcastle's lack of a trained animal companion. The conversation reflects genuine affection for Palace's history and traditions rather than detailed match analysis.
The Red and Blue Believers
These fans are riding the high of victory with pure, uncomplicated pride in the Eagles, celebrating the win as a moment of genuine triumph for their club's identity.
admiration
approval
"@CPFC Good win palace. #eagles #cpfc #boom"
"@CPFC What a turnaround. UP THE PALACE!"
The Pragmatic Debate Squad
They're dissecting what the result means beneath the surface—questioning decisions, legacy calls, and the broader narratives that define Palace's season—without getting swept up in the emotion.
neutral
"@King_LeonReport @CPFC Fuck off Chelsea fan"
"@PalacePerch @CPFC @DarrenR_85 He ruined his legacy in January"
The Affectionate Loyalists
These supporters find joy in the oddball, personal ways Palace lives in their lives, from naming their dogs after legends to laughing at their own club's quirks with genuine love.
"Lol best news I've had all day,well done Crystal palace.
😂
🔴⚪️🔴⚪️🔴⚪️🔴"
"And no disrespect to sir bobby I named my puppy staffie after him 💓"
The Exhausted Cynics
They're burnt out on Palace's patterns and predictability, frustrated enough to question why they bother following a team that seems destined to disappoint them over and over again.
"@_mamasu10 @CPFC just support the most predictable team in england unfortunately mate"
"@TerrordeArcd @CPFC Stop talking about Palace then ya fucking spastic"
Newcastle supporters are split on whether Yoane Wissa is genuinely underperforming or simply misused tactically by Eddie Howe, with particular frustration aimed at late substitute appearances that amount to nothing. The broader discussion reflects growing anxiety about squad stagnation and questions whether the manager's methods are failing multiple players rather than any individual being the sole problem.
Howe's Panic Button Brigade
These fans are absolutely fuming that Eddie threw on attacking players with seconds remaining instead of planning ahead — they see it as desperate, reactive management that proves there's no coherent tactical vision.
Joelinton
Joe Willock
"Why the fuck put Wissa and Elanga when we were down with a minute to go? Reactive every time .. so forward planning. Weekend ruined.. cheers Eddie"
"Elanga and wissa on with a minute left in this situation is an awful situation "
The Patient Pragmatists
They're willing to give Joelinton credit for his season-long contributions whilst acknowledging newer signings like Osula might offer more dynamism, taking a measured view rather than rushing to conclusions.
neutral
Joelinton
Joe Willock
"Osula miles better than Wissa/Wolte so far. Let’s see if he has the juice to last 70+ mins "
"He has been good all season, he isn’t perfect but he has shown more than Wissa"
The Sub Timing Sceptics
These fans are baffled by the sheer pointlessness of the substitution decisions themselves — why bring players on for 18 to 24 seconds when it changes nothing except exposing Eddie's lack of planning?
"Only idiots repeat what the journalists say. Remember when Wissa was meant to save our season despite all our issues stemming from the build up?"
"What's the actual point of bringing Wissa on for 24 seconds? Absolutely baffles me, these subs. "
The Fresh Legs Optimists
They're backing the pace and versatility of emerging options like Osula whilst acknowledging the quality in Wissa and Woltemade, suggesting Newcastle's problems run deeper than any individual player.
amusement
Joelinton
Joe Willock
"love wissa and woltemade but ousla has so much pace and can also play left !"
"Elanga and Wissa on for 18 seconds. Nice one Eddie."
Palace supporters are reacting with resignation and dark humour to a devastating 2-1 defeat to Newcastle, with many having moved past fury into a state of bemused despair at their side's performance. The late penalty loss appears to be the final straw for a fanbase already exhausted by the club's struggles this season.
Pure Fury, No Filter
These fans are absolutely seething—they're past the point of rational analysis and just need to scream into the void about how abysmal their team's performance has become.
anger
"Fucking pathetic jesus Christ "
"that’s absolutely pathetic and unacceptable "
Laughing So It Doesn't Hurt
They've cycled through anger so many times that they've reached a dark comedy phase where the collapse is so catastrophic it becomes genuinely funny to them.
"Haha ftm"
"I actually found it funny when they scored. I'm not even angry anymore. That's how bad it's got."
Numb to the Pain
These supporters are caught in that eerie middle ground where they can't decide if they should be furious or resigned, so they're oscillating between both.
"Haha ftm"
"I actually found it funny when they scored. I'm not even angry anymore. That's how bad it's got."
The Calm Analysts
Stepping back from the emotional chaos, these fans are trying to have a measured conversation about what's actually happened and why it matters tactically or strategically.
neutral
"Spot on"
"Now this is an interesting question"
The Rare Bright Spot Merchants
A small but defiant crew finding moments of genuine entertainment or relief in what everyone else sees as total disaster—they're either trolling or genuinely stubborn optimists.
amusement
"Hahaha very good"
"Great. "
Newcastle supporters are heavily criticising right-back Tino Livramento's defensive performance and consistency, with many arguing he should be sold despite his marketable profile, whilst simultaneously praising Lewis Hall as the club's most reliable defender this season. The discussion centres on Livramento's repeated positional mistakes and poor decision-making at the back post, with fans suggesting he'd be better suited to left-back or surplus to requirements entirely.
Livramento's Cost Us The Match
Fans who've seen enough of Livramento's careless errors believe this single moment of madness has actively damaged Newcastle's season and cannot be overlooked or excused.
Jacob Murphy
Harvey Barnes
"Tino Livramento with one of the all time most baffling decisions I’ve ever seen. wtf was that"
"That tino turnover is so painful"
Classic Right-Back Brain Fade
Observers treating this as a typical midfield turnover—frustrating but par for the course—who want to move past the incident rather than dwell on individual blame.
neutral
Jacob Murphy
Harvey Barnes
"Tino is back pass merchant"
"Tino come on my friend that’s a huge opportunity for us to get down the right and now it’s a corner to them."
Hall's The One We Can Trust
Fans pivoting the conversation to compare defensive reliability across the squad, arguing that Newcastle's other full-backs and centre-backs have been far more dependable this season.
"Hall has been the only consistent defender this season, maybe Schar but been injured too much."
"I'd be sad to lose Hall "
"Hall has been the only consistent defender this season, maybe Schar but been injured too much."
"I'd be sad to lose Hall "
"Hall has been the only consistent defender this season, maybe Schar but been injured too much."
"I'd be sad to lose Hall "
Palace supporters are buzzing about Jean-Philippe Mateta's dramatic impact after coming on, with the forward scoring twice in quick succession to snatch a 2-1 comeback victory against Newcastle. Fans are celebrating his mentality and form, with several noting that his introduction fundamentally shifted the game's momentum in Palace's favour.
Mateta's Got You Spooked
Newcastle fans are genuinely rattled by what Mateta does to them, and Palace supporters are absolutely loving the psychological edge their striker has created.
neutral
Joelinton
Joe Willock
"Mateta scares me"
"@ChrisUK1992 @NUFC What happened, did Uncle Mateta hurt you? Crying one here."
Hot And Cold Reactions
Fans are oscillating between celebration and scepticism, caught between the excitement of a match-winning performance and underlying doubts about consistency.
"Palace fans love mateta again I see 😂"
"Go on Mateta boyyy!!"
The Mateta Redemption Arc
Die-hard Palace believers are fully invested in Mateta's comeback story, seeing him as the dependable figurehead who embodies everything the club needed this season.
admiration
love
Joelinton
Joe Willock
"Loving the Mateta celebration and crowd chant ❤❤❤"
"@CPFC Great game and exciting result. I said it strong lineup and depth on the bench. Mr Dependable and Reliable Mateta get the double to secure the maximum points 3 solid point. h"
Reading Between The Lines
Tactical observers are weighing up what the result actually reveals about Palace's squad depth, attacking options, and whether this win exposes weaknesses elsewhere.
"Palace fans love mateta again I see 😂"
"Go on Mateta boyyy!!"
The Fringe Players Aren't Cutting It
A vocal minority reckon the supporting cast around Mateta—particularly Larson and Johnson—lack the pace and impact to sustain this level, and they're worried about Palace's depth going forward.
Joelinton
Joe Willock
"@CPFC Front 3 pimo aside not good enough Larson and Johnson do not effect the game no pace at all"
"@CPFC All 3 poor all subs better players worried about Larson does not effect game"
Newcastle supporters have had enough of manager Eddie Howe following a devastating 2-1 defeat to Crystal Palace, with the consensus shifting decisively toward his removal after months of repetitive, uninspiring performances and tactical stagnation. Fans are pointing to lack of attacking patterns, poor set-piece defending, and questionable team selection as evidence that despite early cup success, Howe's time at St James' Park has run its course.
Eddie Out, Full Stop
These fans believe Howe's tactical decisions and substitution timing cost Newcastle the match, and they've completely run out of patience with his management.
annoyance
eddie
Jacob Murphy
"@NUFC GET EDDIE OUT OF MY FUCKING CLUB. Awful team selection and woeful fucking timing on subs! He’s clueless!"
"@NUFC Whats the excuses eddie - its a fuckin joke, another set of points dropped because u do fuck all when were under the cosh, that murphy selection is a disgrace, ur subs were a"
Absolute Meltdown Mode
Raw, unfiltered anger from supporters processing the defeat in real-time, venting fury at both the manager and players without attempting any deeper analysis.
neutral
eddie
Jacob Murphy
"@NUFC Eddie and the players are complete fucking shite"
"@NUFC Get fucked. Sack Eddie TONIGHT. Don’t even let him back on the bus and don’t even let Murphy back on the fucking bus. Seriously get fucked"
The Calm Verdict
These supporters have made their minds up that Howe must go, but they're expressing it as cold, inevitable fact rather than emotional outburst.
"Eddie has to go"
"Sack Eddie"
Ride or Die Eddie
A tiny, defiant minority backing the manager's decisions and refusing to join the pile-on, clinging to faith when everyone else has abandoned ship.
gratitude
eddie
"@NUFC Never doubted you Eddie great team selection!"
"OH EDDIE WE LOVE YOU OH EDDIE EDDIE "
Crystal Palace and Newcastle supporters are so frustrated with their own team's mediocre performances this season that they're taking comfort in Tottenham's even worse form, repeatedly using Spurs as a benchmark for how bad things could actually be. The desperation is real—fans would rather celebrate rivals' failures than their own results, suggesting deep dissatisfaction with how their sides are operating.
Spurs Collapse is Catharsis
These fans are channelling raw frustration about their own team's failures into schadenfreude, using Tottenham's implosion as emotional release from their own misery.
Nick Pope
Aaron Ramsdale
"Spurs' less shit keeper just got a serious injury, they are fucked"
"Why the fuck would you want those lot to beat Spurs at the risk of finishing below them AND them potentially getting to a European place?
Fucking ridiculous.
You’d rather laugh a"
Spurs Mask Our Own Crisis
This camp recognises that Tottenham's disaster has conveniently buried their team's poor form from scrutiny, and they're simultaneously relieved and darkly amused by the distraction.
"Sometimes I look at a Newcastle fan crashing out and think to myself "atleast you’re not a spurs fan" because my life SUCKS"
"It's a good thing spurs are awful because everyone is overlooking how dreadful we've been this year.
The subs today man, just ridiculous."
Silver Lining Realism
These fans are taking a pragmatic, almost resigned approach—acknowledging that at least their team isn't quite as catastrophic as Spurs, which is the only consolation available.
neutral
point
Nick Pope
"At least we’re not Spurs bad. That’s about the only positive."
"Good things Spurs has all the attention, otherwise we'd be this seasons joke"
Contrarian Advantage Play
This minority believes Spurs' struggles actually benefit their team tactically or competitively, rejecting the consensus misery and instead spotting opportunity in the chaos.
amusement
point
Nick Pope
"More beneficial for us for spurs to win tbh"
"Would love to see a super league breakaway team in the championship"
Newcastle fans are furious that four of their major summer signings—totalling around £200 million—remained on the bench until the final minutes of a 2-1 loss to Crystal Palace, with supporters convinced the manager's squad rotation cost them points and questioning the club's entire transfer strategy. The overwhelming sentiment is one of waste and mismanagement, with fans arguing that such expensive talent sitting unused until the dying stages epitomises a fundamentally broken approach to team building.
The Accountant's Reckoning
Fans doing the brutal maths on transfer spend versus pitch performance, treating the squad like a balance sheet that simply doesn't add up.
neutral
Jacob Murphy
Harvey Barnes
"Just tell yourself the 120 mill we spent on strikers was actually just on a world class osula and you'll be far happier"
"I'd happily take £150m for the pair of them in the summer."
The Betrayal Brigade
Supporters convinced the entire season collapsed the moment their star striker abandoned ship, and now they're watching the club's lavish spending prove utterly pointless without him.
annoyance
disappointment
Jacob Murphy
Harvey Barnes
"This season was ruined the second our star striker downed tools and pissed off to Liverpool and our failure to replace him spunking 120m on bench fodder"
"Absolutely shite man, been coming for a long time. Over 200m of his summer signings still sitting on the bench as well. We're a mess top to bottom."
The Pragmatic Observers
Fans caught between frustration and acceptance, acknowledging both the mess on the pitch and the individual quality still lurking in the squad waiting to break through.
"Some player mateta, would suit Chelsea"
"This season was ruined the second our star striker downed tools and pissed off to Liverpool and our failure to replace him spunking 120m on bench fodder"
The Evidence Gatherers
Supporters dissecting what went wrong with forensic detail, connecting dots between managerial decisions, recruitment failures, and the mounting evidence of systematic underperformance.
"Some player mateta, would suit Chelsea"
"This season was ruined the second our star striker downed tools and pissed off to Liverpool and our failure to replace him spunking 120m on bench fodder"
The Contrarian Believers
A rare breed convinced the doubters have it all backwards, championing overlooked squad members as secretly world-class whilst subtly suggesting the club's hierarchy has massively undervalued their talents.
Jacob Murphy
Harvey Barnes
Yoane Wissa
"Ty is probably the most underrated player in the league. Better than Hall and more experienced than O'Reilly he should be nailed on for the squad but Tuchel has his favourites and "
"Shhhh he is a lethal scoring machine, he is worth at least 100m maybe even 120m, please and thank you "
Crystal Palace supporters are revelling in Newcastle's 2-1 defeat after the visitors threw away a winning position, with fans expressing deep frustration at how much money Newcastle have spent without achieving top-flight consistency or competitive success. The negativity centres on Newcastle's repeated pattern of losing leads this season and the gap between their financial ambition and actual on-pitch results.
Eddie Howe Must Go
The majority are absolutely furious with Newcastle's spineless display and demanding immediate managerial change, convinced that no amount of investment can fix a fundamentally broken tactical approach and lack of character.
anger
annoyance
Eddie
"@NUFC Pathetic spinless performance yet again.Our wingers are so fucking poor"
"@NUFC Is this the response you promised? Fuck me we've been shite!! SAXK THE CUNT!!! @jamiereuben #EDDIEOUT"
We're Miles Off The Pace
This camp is taking a step back to acknowledge the brutal reality: Newcastle are nowhere near the level of genuine title contenders and face a long, dark rebuild ahead.
"newcastle at the moment are a million miles away from the other top flight teams in the premiership. a huge gulf between them. AND they said they are going to be the best team in t"
"Dark times ahead for Newcastle I think...."
Stop Insulting Our Intelligence
Fans are calling out what they see as gaslighting from the club, refusing to accept any narrative that contradicts what their own eyes witnessed on the pitch in a shambolic first half.
neutral
Howe
season
"@NUFC THE FIRST HALF WAS FUCKING SHIT STOP LYING TO US WE HAVE FUCKING EYES MAN ZERO CREATITY IN THIS TEAM"
"@NUFC Were fucking shit, what the fuck have they been doing for the last 3 weeks?"
Second Half Silver Lining
A tiny but vocal minority are clinging to Newcastle's improved second-half showing as evidence of recovery and future hope, unwilling to write off the season despite the wider collapse around them.
Howe
season
"@NUFC And another absolutely stupendous second half , wonderful"
"I cant wait for the TTG video."
Newcastle supporters have erupted in frustration at defender Sven Botman following his clumsy challenge that gifted Crystal Palace a decisive penalty in the 90+4th minute, with fans condemning his defensive lapses and questioning whether the once-promising signing has become a genuine liability. The backlash reflects deeper discontent with Newcastle's defensive stability this season, as Botman's form has nosedived from his impressive debut campaign into what supporters see as a pattern of reckless errors costing the team points.
Botman's Defensive Meltdown
Fans blaming the Dutch defender for a soft penalty decision that exposed what they see as chronic defensive incompetence across two seasons.
annoyance
anger
"That's so fucking soft, but so predictable. Botman and Thiaw are fucking horrendous for howlers."
"He's done fuck and allowed this to happen, so yeah Botman was stupid but we shouldn't be in this position."
The Masked Marvel Narrative
A lighter-hearted contingent embracing the visual drama of Botman's injury mask, treating it as a superhero redemption arc rather than dwelling on the penalty itself.
neutral
"Botman -> Batman transformation progressing nicely."
"I like how masked Botman is playing."
Systemic Defensive Collapse
Analysts arguing that Botman is just one symptom of a wider defensive crisis involving overrated midfielders like Tonali and centre-back partner Thiaw.
"Botman is and has been a terrible defender for two seasons now
Tonali and Thiaw insanely overrated.
The only players worth keeping are Hall and Miley at this point. Glad we bust"
"Was that Botmans Dummett moment"
Masked Botman Believers
A small but vocal group convinced the mask is actually elevating Botman's performance, praising his decision-making and positioning regardless of the penalty outcome.
"Ooooo my god Botman is officially BATMAN with his mask"
"I like how masked Botman is playing."
Crystal Palace supporters are furious with their manager's substitution strategy after a dramatic 2-1 defeat to Newcastle, with fans condemning the decision to make tactical changes only in the 94th and 95th minutes when the match was already lost. The overwhelming criticism centres on a pattern of reactive rather than proactive management throughout the season, with fans arguing that meaningful squad changes should happen far earlier to prevent collapses rather than after damage has been done.
System's Broken, We're Broken
Palace fans convinced both the tactical setup and the players have fundamentally failed them, and nothing short of wholesale change will fix it.
anger
mins
"Knew that was coming and we deserve it. We've been dogshit. The system is dogshit.
And we've made no changes because our manager doesn't fucking like subs. "
"Those subs are fucking embarrassing. "
Subs Eventually Work, Innit
Pragmatic observers noting that Newcastle's substitutions made an obvious difference, delivered with a shrug of resignation about how football works.
neutral
mins
"big subs for them"
"Crazy how making subs can change a game. I wouldn’t know because I am a Newcastle United fan. I bet it’s cool"
Too Little Too Late Merchant
Skeptics who reckon the manager finally got it right with the changes, but only after wasting 70-odd minutes that could've prevented disaster.
"2:25"
"He's so close to understanding. Maybe this time next year he'll use subs well? "
Should've Done It Ages Ago
The sardonic wing convinced the substitution gambit proves the manager had the answers all along but lacked the bottle to deploy them sooner.
amusement
mins
"Subs? A cracking idea. About 15 mins ago"
"Good once we made the subs"
After dropping yet another two points from a winning position against Newcastle, Palace supporters are venting about a season defined by catastrophic inability to hold leads, with fans openly questioning whether the club is setting a dubious record for points thrown away and expressing resignation that they'll languish in mid-table mediocrity all season long.
Just The Facts, Mate
These fans are documenting the carnage with clinical detachment — they're processing what happened without the emotional wreckage, treating losses from winning positions like data points rather than heartbreak.
neutral
games
europe
"It is definitely top 32 of our PL matches played so far this season"
"4. I gotchu "
We're Broken, And I'm Furious
This is the beating heart of Palace's fanbase right now — they're absolutely gutted by the serial collapse from winning positions, and their anger isn't directed at one player or one match, it's at a systemic pattern that's destroying them week after week.
disappointment
games
europe
"My fucking God how sick I am to lose from a winning position"
"i’m so fucking tired of losing winning positions "
Darkly Funny Acceptance
These are the fans who've reached peak disillusionment and found comedy in the chaos — they're joking about being Championship material and accepting their own incompetence with sardonic humour because the alternative is screaming into the void.
games
europe
"We look like a top tier Championship squad with this lineup"
"Only 6 points from 6th!
j/k, we’re exactly where we deserve to be."
Palace supporters are at breaking point after the loss, with frustration boiling over at what they see as blind optimism from more forgiving fans who continue to back the team without demanding change. Even traditionally patient supporters admit they've been "worn down" by the club's performances, and the fanbase is fracturing between those demanding accountability and those defending the players.
Rage Against The Machine
These fans are absolutely seething at the weekend's display, directing their fury at both the players' perceived lack of fight and the "happy clappers" they believe are enabling mediocrity with false positivity.
annoyance
weekend
Jacob Murphy
"@NUFC Spineless stupid fucking cunt why is there away fans clapping him in the fucking stands for you know how embarrassing that is? We had 3 weeks off they planned 3 days ago and "
"@CPFC Are your pathetic fans still booing Mateta and Glasner?"
Pragmatists Finding Silver Linings
They acknowledge the defeat stings, but they're capable of holding multiple truths at once — frustration with results sits alongside appreciation for life's bigger picture, even as they mock the relentless optimists around them.
"Well this is a bummer, but my son got recognized for sportsmanship over the weekend, so all in all a great weekend. "
"Can't wait for the happy clappers to come and make excuses.
They'll be plumbing to new depths whatever they come up with.
"
Fed-Up Realists Demanding Change
These supporters have moved beyond anger into cold clarity — they see the happy clapping culture as a genuine problem and believe it's time for drastic action, whether that means sacking the manager or changing the entire mentality.
neutral
weekend
Jacob Murphy
"Well this is a bummer, but my son got recognized for sportsmanship over the weekend, so all in all a great weekend. "
"NO MORE FUCKING HAPPY CLAPPING SACK HIM"
The Rare Contented Minority
A tiny fraction genuinely found reasons to celebrate the weekend, either because they're Newcastle fans enjoying Palace's slip-up or because they've successfully prioritised wellbeing over match results.
joy
weekend
"@NUFC Happy clappers will be delighted with that one"
"Well this is a bummer, but my son got recognized for sportsmanship over the weekend, so all in all a great weekend. "
Crystal Palace and Newcastle supporters vented their frustration at a tedious, tension-filled 0-0 draw that left viewers feeling they'd wasted their afternoon watching uninspiring football. The overwhelmingly negative sentiment reflects fans' exhaustion with the lack of quality entertainment, with several admitting they'd rather have been doing anything else than enduring the match's slow, anxiety-inducing pace.
The Unwatchable Waste Brigade
These fans view the match as an insult to their time, a drab snoozefest where even the aesthetics—the pitch, the kits, the cameras—conspired to make it worse.
annoyance
disappointment
"This is borderline unwatchable. A good game would at least balance out the ugly pitch, ugly camera angle and ugly kit. But no. Insipid blandness it is. "
"Another awful 2 hours to have eyes and ears."
The Fence-Sitters
Too detached to fully condemn the display, they're matching the match's own apathy with shrugs and deflection, treating the whole thing as background noise.
neutral
"I find these threads generally match the output on the pitch and today is no different"
"Is there anything better than multiscreening?"
The "Just Don't Watch" Crowd
Pragmatic voices offering a simple escape hatch to the complainers—if you hate it that much, why are you here tormenting yourself?
"Don't look at the match thread then"
"Probably because its such a non-event that they never bother showing it."
The Result Readers
Moving past the theatre of it all to focus on what actually matters—the three points—even if the journey to get them was utterly forgettable.
"Don't look at the match thread then"
"Probably because its such a non-event that they never bother showing it."
The Ironic Defenders
A tiny rebel faction sarcastically celebrating the nothing-burger as premium Premier League content, mocking the very concept that entertainment should exist in football.
"Great stuff this. PL at its finest.
They should include this in the showreel when negotiating the next set of telly rights."
"Is there anything better than multiscreening?"
A 90+4' penalty awarded to Crystal Palace's Jean-Philippe Mateta has sparked fierce debate amongst supporters, with Newcastle fans split between those believing it was a clear shirt-pull and those insisting it was a soft or non-existent foul that cost their side the match. The decision proved decisive in a 2-1 defeat that has left Magpies supporters frustrated and questioning the referee's interpretation of contact in the closing moments.
Refs Are Killing The Game
These fans believe the referee made a clear error that cost Newcastle the result, and they're furious that late-game decisions—especially dubious penalties—are systematically ruining football's integrity.
annoyance
anger
Kieran Trippier
Dan Burn
"God i hate refs, that was never a pen.
Doesnt help we play shit every game along side it, but i hate watching football currently."
"I like genuinely want to start to see fines for goals conceded after 80 minutes. What the fuck is wrong with them "
Instant Reaction Dismissal
These supporters are catching the decision in real time, processing the shock and unfairness of what they've just witnessed without yet committing to deeper analysis.
"Joke of a pen"
"That can't be a pen looked like the wind pushed him over"
The Forensic Fence-Sitters
These fans are willing to interrogate the evidence from multiple angles and will actually change their mind if the replay shows contact, treating it as a genuine technical question rather than an emotional one.
neutral
Kieran Trippier
Dan Burn
"I thought so too at first with the camera angle, but the replay showed it was some tremendous heads up play."
"Man’s flying"
The Clever-Play Defenders
This small but vocal minority reckon the defending player got done by smart attackerism—they see the contact and the fall as legitimate consequences of the forward's movement, not simulation.
Kieran Trippier
Dan Burn
"Good improvisation at least lol"
"Pulled back and falls forward.
Clever stuff. Well done."
Newcastle supporters are hammering Anthony Gordon and Harvey Barnes for their woeful performances in the match, with particular vitriol aimed at their lack of effort, poor decision-making, and complete anonymity on the wing. Fans are questioning whether Barnes is anywhere near good enough to deputise if Gordon leaves, with some arguing he offered virtually nothing to the team's attacking play.
Gordon's Lost The Plot
This camp believes Gordon delivered a genuinely unacceptable performance — lacking intensity, effort, and the mentality Newcastle need — and they're furious he's wasting his talent with a jogging, careless display.
annoyance
anger
Kieran Trippier
Dan Burn
"Fuck Gordon man, he doesn’t give a fuck "
"Utter dross this. Again I’m left thinking what are we even trying to do here, where the fuck is the intensity?Gordon absolutely gash. "
Watching And Noting The Details
This crew are neutral commentators simply tracking what's happening on the pitch, crediting good moments when they see them but refusing to get emotionally wound up either way.
neutral
Kieran Trippier
Dan Burn
"Gordon playing a lot more centrally and in between the lines. If we can find him in the pocket we can create something good."
"Easy pass there Gordon, good play before that though"
The Broken Promise Reckoning
These fans are drawing painful comparisons to past Newcastle failures, questioning whether Gordon and Barnes are actually capable of delivering when it matters most, and wondering if selling one to replace the other solves anything.
"Gordon reminded me today of Owen in that game where we only needed a goal to stay up and he was jogging around not giving AF."
"Another game where Harvey Barnes offers absolutely fuck all. If we sell Gordon and have him starting LW we're actually fucked. He's nowhere near good enough. "
Glimpses Of Quality Exist
A small but optimistic minority pointing out that Gordon's had genuinely bright moments — good passes, intelligent movement — and arguing the narrative has swung too far into negativity.
Kieran Trippier
Dan Burn
"Lovely pass to Strand Larson from Gordon to setup the corner. "
"@NUFC_Fanatic @NUFC Gordon’s been our best player this half"
Newcastle supporters are divided over excuses following their 2-1 loss to Crystal Palace, with some pointing to inadequate training time due to international commitments whilst others dismiss this and demand accountability for consistently poor attacking and defensive display. The broader frustration centres on the team's structural inability to create chances from open play and their vulnerability when opponents attack, with fans rejecting the narrative that three weeks' preparation should have made a difference.
The Break Made Us Worse
Furious fans convinced that Newcastle's two-week layoff actively damaged the team's rhythm and cohesion, turning preparation time into a liability rather than an advantage.
annoyance
disappointment
Kieran Trippier
Nick Pope
"A two-week break to reconvene and we lose to the same fucking shit. "
"Why did yous think a 3 week break would help our team? Our performance goes to shit after a 15 minute break, multiplying that by thousands isnt gonna do anything "
No Excuses Left to Hide Behind
Level-headed supporters acknowledging that with a fully fit squad and proper preparation time, there's simply nowhere left to point fingers — the performance speaks for itself.
neutral
Kieran Trippier
Nick Pope
"So one positive of watching our team this season is the intense first 10-15 minutes. We have had three weeks on the training pitch and look like asthmatics"
".
He has had 2 weeks to prepare for this game. Our squad is healthy right now, there is no excuse "
Same Broken System, Different Week
Cynical observers who've given up waiting for change, believing the core problems — tactics, selection, mentality — remain utterly unchanged regardless of circumstances or preparation.
"so whats the excuses this time eh nufc. you have probably got about 10 lined up. just admit you were beaten by a better team just like you were beaten off us lot sunderland he he !"
"This is the team it’s been all season. Lineup, tactics, previous matches, next matches, none of it matters. We are just always this team. Can’t create anything from open play. Desp"
The Long Game Pays Off Eventually
Rare optimists clinging to faith that the intensive training block will compound into results soon, viewing this loss as a necessary step in a bigger plan.
Kieran Trippier
Nick Pope
"We are so fucking good, all part of the plan"
"Let's see how good that training has been"
Newcastle supporters are furious with Eddie Howe after blowing a lead to lose 2-1 to Crystal Palace, with hundreds of posts demanding his sacking and criticising his tactical nous and inability to manage games. Fans argue that despite massive investment, the manager has failed to deliver and is too protected by the media, with some claiming Newcastle have lost more points from winning positions than any other top-five league side this season.
Howe's System Has Failed Us
This camp believes the manager's tactical setup is fundamentally broken and has left Newcastle with no creativity, no plan B, and no way to compete when the opposition sits deep.
annoyance
disappointment
howe
Kieran Trippier
"@NUFC Fucking dog shit, 3 week break and we put in a performance like that? Howe needs to go. No plan B. Players look fucked. What the fucks happening at this club. Get his nephew "
"@NUFC Can't be assed with this lot anymore! So shit to watch, no energy! No creativity, Howes system is god awful! Wake the fuck up and smell the roses!"
Stuck Between Anger and Denial
These fans are so raw from the result they're cycling through contradictory takes — some defending Howe out of habit whilst simultaneously demanding he leaves — unable to process what they've just witnessed.
neutral
howe
Kieran Trippier
"Let's go Eddie Howe in ❤️❤️"
"@NUFC Fucking useless the lot of them. Get Howe out TODAY"
The Sarcasm Brigade
This group has moved past fury into bitter mockery, using irony to express their belief that Howe gets undeserved credit from sections of the media and fanbase despite consistent underperformance when it matters.
"I give up Howe OUT"
"Cant wait to hear how amazing Eddie Howe is again 😂"
Crystal Palace supporters are furious with their team's disorganised, individualistic defending and one-dimensional attacking approach—constantly criticising poor positioning, lack of leadership, and a predictable passing strategy that relies too heavily on wing play rather than creating genuine scoring opportunities. Fans are calling for radical tactical changes and questioning player commitment, with many arguing the squad needs wholesale changes to compete at this level.
We're Actually Embarrassing Ourselves
Fans convinced Palace's basic fundamentals—passing, crossing, shooting—have completely collapsed and that the current system is beyond repair.
anger
disappointment
Jacob Murphy
Harvey Barnes
"Jesus fucking Christ we cannot pass or cross or shoot the ball "
"the way we fuck up the simplest of passes in key positions. It’s just so pathetic"
Let's Just Look At The Facts
Pragmatists documenting what actually happened on the pitch without emotional judgement, pointing out defensive merit and statistical reality.
neutral
Jacob Murphy
Harvey Barnes
"72% pass success in 2nd half for us..."
"Really good defending by Thiaw. Easy to give away a penalty in those situations."
We Need a Complete Reset
Tactical activists demanding radical formation changes and leadership overhaul because the current setup has lost control of the midfield and individual discipline.
"Maybe against Bournemouth we could just try something different, like 4-4-2, 5-3-2, 3-3-4, 0-0-10… anything that gives us two bloody forwards on the pitch at the same time from the"
"Defending as individuals so much this season. Everyone doing their own thing. We need a leader there. Burn’s the best at that but even then it’s mostly just him shouting at people "
When We Play Right, Magic Happens
The rare optimists seizing on Palace's brief moments of attacking fluidity as proof the team can click if given the right platform.
Jacob Murphy
Harvey Barnes
"We've been trying this quick passing all game. It finally worked. Who knew playing quick football can catch teams out?!"
"First bit of decent passing we've had"
Newcastle supporters are venting frustration after losing 2-1 to struggling Crystal Palace, with criticism directed at manager Eddie Howe's tactical approach, poor attacking play, lack of squad rotation for key signings, and a perceived lack of urgency given Palace's poor season form. The fanbase views the result as a damning indictment of the club's direction, with many calling for immediate managerial change and questioning whether European qualification is now out of reach.
The Excuses Brigade
These fans reckon Newcastle's loss was just bad timing and fixture congestion, refusing to acknowledge Palace earned a genuine victory.
neutral
Kieran Trippier
Dan Burn
"@SvenSzn2 @NUFC We’re lucky palace just had a game mid week"
"Post-Easter Palace form is not to be trifled with"
The Reckoning Has Come
They're done making excuses—these supporters believe the squad's recruitment failures and flat performances have finally caught up with them.
disappointment
place
Kieran Trippier
Nick Pope
"We don't deserve anything, we've been awful and flat all day. We had one shot (and goal) against Palace when they had their best players on the bench. Nowhere near good enough. B"
"Palace, 4th home league win, first time at home to come from behind to win! Just fucking sums this season up for us. Absolute dog shit. And some of these players want Champion’s le"
The Uncomfortable Truth Tellers
This camp's wrestling with a harder reality: Palace are actually in form, Newcastle's recruitment outside Thiaw and Ramsey has been dodgy, and today exposed deeper structural problems.
"Media want to make out Palace are struggling. Last 6 matches in all competitions Palace have won 4 and drawn 2"
"I hate saying it but today I've honestly had enough poor recruitment minus Thiaw and Ramsey and too many games like today he's made poor judgement we had to make changes sooner pal"
The Outliers In The Room
A tiny minority celebrating the result itself rather than Newcastle's loss, these fans are either trolls or genuinely disconnected from the broader fan sentiment.
joy
Kieran Trippier
Dan Burn
"glad to see crystal palace win against new castle you dont see this everyday"
"God Im glad we have Hometown Hero played at our home games."
Palace supporters are venting their frustration at what they perceive as an endless pattern of mid-table stagnation and predictable underperformance, with many expressing exhaustion at the prospect of years more of the same struggle. The negative mood reflects a deeper despair about the club's trajectory rather than reaction to any single match result.
Exhausted by the Same Old Story
These fans have reached boiling point because Palace keep finding fresh ways to self-destruct week after week, and they're furious that the club's capacity for embarrassment feels limitless.
anger
"FFS. This is just embarrassing. Fresh ways to fuck games week after week. "
"I fucking hate this team "
Numb to the Disappointment
This contingent has emotionally checked out entirely — they've accepted mediocrity as Palace's default setting and are now just counting down the fixtures until the season ends.
neutral
"Always is"
"Can't wait for the season to end "
Newcastle supporters are tearing into Jacob Murphy's performance in the 0-0 draw with Crystal Palace, with 54 touches and 25 possession losses highlighting his ineffectiveness — but the real anger stems from deeper frustrations about squad morale, with fans convinced key players like Tonali, Gordon and Tino have checked out mentally and questioning whether manager Eddie Howe's entire project is collapsing. The discussion spirals from individual criticism into broader fears about summer departures, PSR constraints, and a return to mid-table mediocrity.
Murphy's A Liability Now
Fans absolutely fuming that the captain delivered a genuinely unacceptable performance, viewing his display as symptomatic of a broader rot in the squad's mentality and work ethic.
anger
annoyance
won
season
"Murphy was fucking shite and is fucking shite. The fact he was the captain today is an embarrassment- has he won won a fucking raffle or something?"
"@NUFC @AaronRamsdale98 Playing fucking shit btw.. 3 weeks to work with this and this is the dross you're serving?? PUT A STRIKER ON THE PITCH! Osula and Murphy are championship lev"
Classic Murphy Stinker
Level-headed observers recognising Murphy simply had an off day without getting hysterical about it, acknowledging poor form happens to good players.
neutral
Murphy
players
"Murphy's having himself a nice little stinker "
"@NUFC At what point in that game did anyone with working eyes think to themselves “Jacob Murphy looks really good, we should keep him on”?"
The Numbers Don't Lie
Data-focused fans cutting through the emotion to dissect what actually happened on the pitch—54 touches, 25 lost possessions—building a forensic case about Newcastle's creative midfield problem.
"Jacob Murphy touched the ball 54 times and lost possession 25 times, those are crazy stats."
"If Elanga had started on the right and had performed equally as badly (as he has done all season) you’d still be calling Eddie for picking him over Murphy. "
Context Is Everything
Pragmatists questioning whether the anger is fair or whether other underperforming players get the same stick, suggesting selective outrage depending on who's wearing the shirt.
"Jacob Murphy touched the ball 54 times and lost possession 25 times, those are crazy stats."
"If Elanga had started on the right and had performed equally as badly (as he has done all season) you’d still be calling Eddie for picking him over Murphy. "
Newcastle and Crystal Palace fans are furious at referee Andre Madley for allowing Crystal Palace's Munoz to repeatedly foul throughout the match without receiving a yellow card, with supporters arguing he committed multiple offences that should have resulted in a booking. The controversy centres on the inconsistency of the officiating, particularly given that Munoz's persistent fouling went largely unpunished whilst other players received cautions, leading fans to question Madley's management of the game.
Munoz's Dirty Pattern Ignored
Fans convinced the referee bottled a straightforward disciplinary call, viewing Munoz's persistent fouling throughout the match as a deliberate pattern that Madley completely failed to police.
annoyance
anger
game
"Fuck me munoz is dirty like "
"All game that Munoz cunt has fouled us and played dirty. Ref is a moron who loves to lick whistles"
Did The Ref Miss It?
Supporters genuinely uncertain whether the challenge warranted a booking, split between acknowledging Munoz's occasional excess and questioning if the referee simply lost sight of the incident in real time.
neutral
game
"Hall got lucky there, had no idea Muñoz was that close I think haha"
"Fuck off show a yellow to Munoz you coward "
Crystal Palace snatched a 2-1 comeback victory over Newcastle in the 90th minute through a disputed penalty, but fans are furious with Newcastle's manager for repeatedly blaming "uncharacteristic" lapses when the pattern of dropping points from winning positions has defined their entire season. The overwhelming sentiment is one of exasperation—supporters are demanding accountability rather than excuses, viewing this latest collapse as symptomatic of deeper structural problems within the club.
Management Accountability Meltdown
Newcastle fans demanding answers from the dugout, arguing that repeated defensive collapses aren't bad luck—they're a systematic failure that falls squarely on the manager's shoulders.
"@NUFC “Don’t know where that comes from” That’s your job. As manager. To fix that shit. It’s happened all season. Clearly no fucking answers to our problems. “Sometimes that just h"
"@NUFC It’s not uncharacteristic as it happens every fucking week. Where’s your fucking accountability man"
Pattern Recognition, Not Anomaly
Observers calling out the uncomfortable truth that this latest disaster isn't an outlier but the defining characteristic of Newcastle's entire season.
neutral
"@NUFC That was the blueprint NUFC performance if I’ve ever seen one.
Nothing ‘uncharacteristic’ about that."
"Unforgivable was months ago. This is just the newest low "
The Numbers Don't Lie Tribunal
Fans weaponising statistics to settle the debate once and for all, insisting that when something happens consistently, it stops being characteristic and becomes the identity.
"It's absolutely characteristic. Stats don't lie."
"At what point does it become characteristic? It's happened all season"
Data-Driven Defence Breakdown
Analytically-minded supporters using evidence and trends to dissect whether Newcastle's defensive woes reflect individual errors or deeper tactical problems baked into the system.
"It's absolutely characteristic. Stats don't lie."
"At what point does it become characteristic? It's happened all season"
Resigned Acceptance Club
Fans who've moved past anger into a grim, almost numb recognition that this is simply who Newcastle are now—catastrophe has become the baseline expectation.
"It's absolutely characteristic. Stats don't lie."
"At what point does it become characteristic? It's happened all season"
Newcastle United supporters are furious that Joelinton's 74th-minute yellow card forced him to miss crucial matches after he received a second booking late in the game for a challenge that cost his side the win. Fans are resigned to the inevitability of Joelinton picking up needless cautions, with some arguing the suspension wasn't worth the defensive lapse that led to Crystal Palace's penalty.
The Ref's Ruined Everything
This camp believes the yellow card was a catastrophic and unjust decision that fundamentally altered the match and cost Newcastle a result they deserved.
anger
Kieran Trippier
Nick Pope
"Joe, mate, what the fuck was that?! "
"Should have been a red on joelinton, absolutely disgusting tackle"
Big Joe's Letting Us Down
These fans are less interested in debating the decision and more focused on Joelinton's actual performance — they reckon he's been playing poorly and this suspension just compounds an existing problem.
neutral
Kieran Trippier
Nick Pope
"Two matches without big Joe fuck"
"Big Joe has been woeful so far 👎"
The Tactical Trap
This group sees the bigger picture: once Joelinton picked up yellow, the opposition exploited it ruthlessly, exposing weaknesses in Newcastle's defensive shape and decision-making.
"Done it again, Joe can’t bring the man down because he has a yellow and the defence has switched off. Mint"
"so Big Joe out of Arsenal?"
Looking Ahead to Arsenal
These fans are already shifting focus to the next fixture and worrying about squad availability, treating the incident as part of the broader puzzle of managing a season-long campaign.
"Done it again, Joe can’t bring the man down because he has a yellow and the defence has switched off. Mint"
"so Big Joe out of Arsenal?"
Cross-Cutting Patterns
Jacob Murphy
Appears across 8 debates: Palace's Dramatic Late Win Sparks Controversial Debate, Crystal Palace Fans Demand Tactical Overhaul After Newcastle Draw, Newcastle Fans Debate Osula's Performance in Goalless Draw, Crystal Palace Fans Turn on "Happy Clappers" After Defeat, Newcastle Fans Turn on Eddie After Palace Heartbreak, Palace and Newcastle Fans Debate Toothless Attacking Performances, Newcastle's £200m Bench Gamble Backfires in Palace Draw, Newcastle Fans Debate Livramento's Future After Defensive Errors
Kieran Trippier
Appears across 7 debates: Ramsdale Debate as Palace Snatch Dramatic Late Winner, Newcastle Fans Fume as Joelinton's Yellow Card Costs Them, Newcastle Fans Turn on Howe After Palace Collapse, Newcastle Fans Furious with Gordon and Barnes Display, Newcastle Fans Divided Over Controversial Late Penalty, Newcastle Fans Demand Change After Palace Defeat, Newcastle Fans Blame Preparation After Palace Defeat
Harvey Barnes
Appears across 6 debates: Palace's Dramatic Late Win Sparks Controversial Debate, Crystal Palace Fans Demand Tactical Overhaul After Newcastle Draw, Newcastle Fans Debate Osula's Performance in Goalless Draw, Palace and Newcastle Fans Debate Toothless Attacking Performances, Newcastle's £200m Bench Gamble Backfires in Palace Draw, Newcastle Fans Debate Livramento's Future After Defensive Errors
Joelinton
Appears across 5 debates: Crystal Palace Fans Hail Mateta's Match-Winning Second Half Display, Newcastle Fans Debate Wissa's Future as Howe Era Falters, Newcastle Fans Debate Osula's Performance in Goalless Draw, Newcastle Fans Divided Over Miley Display in Palace Draw, Newcastle Fans Clash Over Striker's Ability and Chances
Joe Willock
Appears across 5 debates: Crystal Palace Fans Hail Mateta's Match-Winning Second Half Display, Newcastle Fans Debate Wissa's Future as Howe Era Falters, Newcastle Fans Debate Osula's Performance in Goalless Draw, Newcastle Fans Divided Over Miley Display in Palace Draw, Newcastle Fans Clash Over Striker's Ability and Chances