Everton fans are at war with each other over Jordan Pickford's extraordinary long-range throw that shaped this 2-2 draw, with some furious at the moment and others celebrating it outright — and that division mirrors a bigger frustration across both sets of supporters about David Moyes' defensive approach costing Everton when a win was there for the taking. Crystal Palace and Everton fans are split on whether this point keeps them alive or marks another opportunity missed, with Mateta's dramatic leveller doing just enough to spark optimism even as the reality sinks in: both sides are now staring down the barrel of a season that could've been so much more.
Positive 15.2%
Neutral 28.7%
Negative 56.1%
Here's the thing — Everton fans came away from Selhurst Park furious at another dropped opportunity, with the bulk of supporters trying to stay measured but seething underneath. You've got early optimism when Tarkowski gives them the lead abroad, but by full time the narrative had flipped entirely: a 2-2 draw felt like a defeat, and the frustration centred on defensive vulnerability and a team that simply cannot grind out results when the stakes are highest. For a fanbase already weary after months of inconsistency, this felt less like a valiant comeback performance and more like another chapter in a book nobody wants to keep reading.
Neutral
79.1%
"@Everton Cant wait for the day I can be proud of this team!"
Disappointment
10.6%
"@Everton Why can’t we fucking win when it matters the most! So fucking tired of this shit."
Annoyance
10.3%
"@Everton Why can’t we fucking win when it matters the most! So fucking tired of this shit."
Positive 33.2%
Neutral 41.1%
Negative 25.7%
Crystal Palace supporters were largely level-headed about Mateta's dramatic leveller, with most fans focusing their energy on praising Sarr's earlier equaliser rather than getting swept up in the emotion of the 77th-minute rescue act. The fanbase's reaction split between straightforward appreciation for the goal itself and genuine excitement about what's ahead—particularly that midweek trip to Manchester—suggesting they view this draw as a moment to build on rather than celebrate or lament. What's striking is how little the post-match commentary chaos seems to have registered with supporters; they're simply glad the team showed second-half resilience, and they're already looking forward.
Neutral
76.8%
"@CPFC We’re thrilled to support Crystal Palace and can’t wait to see you shine in Manchester on Wednesday! We’re hyping up the May 13 clash in Manches"
Admiration
16.3%
"@CPFC That's great so welcome to second half team"
Approval
6.8%
"@CPFC Awesome goal by Sarr"
Positive 17.0%
Neutral 37.0%
Negative 45.9%
Everton fans are staring down a brutal reality after that Palace draw: the European dream is dead, and they're not even trying to hide it. Two points dropped against a side sitting fourteenth has crystallised what many supporters already suspected—that this squad, particularly at the back and in midfield, simply isn't good enough to mount a proper push for the continent. What's striking is how resigned the mood feels; there's acceptance here rather than anger, almost a collective shrug at the inevitability of finishing tenth and watching Europe pass them by once again.
Neutral
61.4%
"10th place finish it is boys!"
Disappointment
21.7%
"That's the end of Europe. People can complain about the quality of the centre forwards but they will not be the reason we miss out. 16 non penalty goa"
Optimism
16.9%
"Top half would be fantastic from where we have been. Its still possible we finish 13th or 14th. "
Positive 29.7%
Neutral 36.9%
Negative 33.3%
Here's the thing: Beto came off the pitch with serious plaudits after that 2-2 draw, and the vast majority of Palace and neutral fans were singing his praises in a remarkably unified way. His movement off the ball and the precision of his through-ball play kept drawing admiration—fans were rewatching moments in slow-motion, genuinely impressed by how he'd kept Everton ticking over in midfield. There was barely a whimper of criticism; this wasn't a polarising performance, it was straight-up recognition that he'd done his job and done it well.
Neutral
76.1%
"Betos runs are really good, the though ball is on time and time again."
Admiration
17.0%
"Betos runs are really good, the though ball is on time and time again."
Anger
6.8%
"Barry just looks lazy compared to Beto. Walking in offsides position is so infuriating."
Positive 20.2%
Neutral 45.2%
Negative 34.5%
Right, so here's the thing — this draw left both sets of supporters absolutely torn in half. You've got nearly two-thirds of the fanbase sitting in that numb, deflated middle ground where nobody's happy but nobody's furious either, whilst a fifth of them are absolutely seething because chances like this don't come around often when you're scrapping in the middle of the table. And then there's a smaller pocket of Palace and Everton fans clinging to the positives — a goal, a performance, maybe a player putting in the work — because when you're 14th and 10th respectively, you've got to find something to celebrate before it slips away entirely.
Neutral
63.8%
"Yeah I think you nailed it "
Anger
20.7%
"That was so so fucking shit"
Approval
15.5%
"Yeah I think you nailed it "
Positive 8.5%
Neutral 28.2%
Negative 63.4%
Everton's defence fell apart early, and fans weren't holding back—Tarkowski's opener arrived with barely a minute on the clock, and the immediate reaction was ice-cold annoyance at Michael Keane's performance, with supporters questioning whether he's simply not good enough at this level. The frustration built throughout the match as Palace clawed back to level things up, leaving the fanbase convinced that Keane's individual errors in the Derby and beyond are becoming impossible to ignore. Most remained measured in their disappointment, but the underlying message was clear: they've run out of patience with a defender who keeps costing them points.
Neutral
81.1%
"Tarks and Keane sleeping. Well done."
Annoyance
9.4%
"@Everton Michael Keane has been absolute dog shit since coming on in the derby.
Costing us goals every match!"
Disapproval
9.4%
"Keane just isn’t fucking good enough"
Positive 1.4%
Neutral 31.9%
Negative 66.7%
Here's the thing — the referee decision that sparked this chaos has left fans genuinely baffled rather than furious, with nearly seven in ten supporters staying neutral even as frustration bubbled underneath. What's wild is the confusion itself: some supporters are convinced the commentators aired the disallowed goal, others are baffled at what the official actually did, and a few have just accepted it as par for the course with a dose of gallows humour. The annoyance that did crop up cuts straight at the referee's competence — fans aren't just angry about the call, they're angry that someone getting paid professional wages can't seem to get the basics right.
Neutral
68.9%
"Didn’t know he could do that. FairPlay. COYB "
Confusion
17.8%
"SO STUPID THEY GET PAYED TO DISALLOW GOALS"
Annoyance
13.3%
"I've never seen a clearer pen in my life. This ref is absolutely awful. Gotta be one of the worst in the prem."
Positive 41.3%
Neutral 46.0%
Negative 12.7%
Here's the thing — Everton fans walked away from this draw buzzing about one man: Rohl. The overwhelming reaction was pure admiration for his two-way play and his willingness to drive forward, with supporters genuinely impressed that he's seized his opportunity both defensively and going forward. It wasn't just about his football either — his appearance became part of the narrative, which tells you how much goodwill he's built in such a short time at Goodison.
Neutral
73.2%
"Rohl is so good man, plus his hair is glorious"
Admiration
21.4%
"Rohl is so good man, plus his hair is glorious"
Love
5.4%
"Merlin Röhl is my new favorite "
Positive 6.7%
Neutral 33.3%
Negative 60.0%
Here is the thing: Crystal Palace fans have turned on Ismaïla Sarr's finishing in this one, with a player — likely someone they'd hoped would spark their attack — fluffing his lines when it mattered most, and the anger is raw because you're watching someone overthink the simple art of putting the ball in the back of the net when defenders are nowhere near him. The vast majority stayed composed, but the frustration boiling through those posts tells you everything about a side fighting for every point in mid-table: when you're this far down the league, you cannot afford to waste one-on-one opportunities, and today that lesson was learned the hard way.
Neutral
77.5%
"Did great with the burst if pace initially kdh.. over thunk it innthe end "
Anger
12.5%
"Jesus fucking Christ KDH’s one on ones are awful"
Disappointment
10.0%
"Not had someone this bad at 1 on 1s since DCL"
Positive 1.9%
Neutral 19.2%
Negative 78.8%
Here's the thing—when the final whistle went on that 2-2 draw, both sets of supporters found themselves trapped in that maddening middle ground where nobody quite knows whether to celebrate or scream. The anger and frustration absolutely dominated the conversation, with fans on both sides recognising they'd had chances to actually *win* the match but instead had surrendered soft goals that left them feeling robbed. You're looking at a team that's now become synonymous with capitulation in the closing stages—you get your noses in front, you think you've cracked it, and then late on the whole thing collapses. That's not bad luck. That's a pattern. That's the sort of thing that does a supporter's head in, week after week.
Neutral
54.1%
"
We didn’t lose!"
Disappointment
24.3%
"This team can't never stop letting us down"
Anger
21.6%
"This team does my fucking head in…"
Positive 16.0%
Neutral 32.0%
Negative 52.0%
Everton fans are caught between grudging respect for the atmosphere their travelling support created and genuine fury at how their side failed to capitalise on a Palace team that never looked properly engaged. The overwhelming emotion here isn't just disappointment at dropping points—it's the sting of feeling their squad should have been far more clinical, that a team with European ambitions has no business struggling to break down opponents who seemed to be going through the motions.
Neutral
70.0%
"Best fans in the world "
Disapproval
16.7%
"if we cant beat a hungover palace we dont deserve europe"
Disappointment
13.3%
"@Everton Embarrassing stuff. Palace aren't arsed at all and we still collapse."
Positive 6.2%
Neutral 39.6%
Negative 54.2%
Everton fans were remarkably measured in their frustration with Ndiaye despite a genuinely woeful display at Selhurst Park, with most acknowledging his work rate even as they questioned his final product and decision-making. The criticism centred on his complete absence in possession and creative output rather than effort — fans recognised he pressed and dribbled with intensity, but pointed out it counted for nothing when the basics weren't there. What's telling is the resignation rather than rage: supporters were already moving on to talk about shifting him out, a sign they've given up on the midfielder turning this season around.
Neutral
77.1%
"@BallerTalk0 @Everton Rohl was better than Ndiaye today."
Disappointment
14.3%
"@Everton KDH and ndiaye once again the 2 worst players on the pitch. Time to cash out both wank"
Annoyance
8.6%
"@Everton KDH and ndiaye once again the 2 worst players on the pitch. Time to cash out both wank"
Positive 2.1%
Neutral 17.0%
Negative 80.9%
Crystal Palace supporters have absolutely lost patience with their team's defending, and frankly, it's impossible to blame them—Everton's goals laid bare a defence that looked completely unorganised, with no one stepping up to block passes or cover space when it mattered. The anger is raw and direct here: fans aren't looking for excuses, they're demanding to know why basic defensive structure keeps falling apart, especially when the side had equalised and had chances to take control of the match. What started as a draw that maybe felt acceptable has turned sour because the manner of those Everton goals—the sloppiness, the lack of urgency—suggests something's fundamentally broken in how Palace are setting up and communicating at the back.
Neutral
64.9%
"Holy fuck our defending is complete and utter shit. How the fuck is no one stepping up into that?"
Anger
29.7%
"Holy fuck our defending is complete and utter shit. How the fuck is no one stepping up into that?"
Curiosity
5.4%
"@Everton We’ve had some great chances, why can’t we we put the ball in the back of the net? COYB 💙"
Positive 27.7%
Neutral 55.3%
Negative 17.0%
Here's the thing: with the score locked at two-two deep into the second half, both sets of supporters were absolutely on edge, desperate for that late winner to settle it. You can feel the tension crackling through the posts — Palace and Everton fans aren't celebrating what they've got, they're clawing for more, wanting that crucial cushion to put the game to bed. And it makes total sense, because in a campaign where both sides are scrapping for position in the middle of the table, one more goal could be the difference between momentum and heartbreak.
Neutral
71.4%
"I can feel it, our winner "
Desire
20.0%
"Omg please score id quite like a 2 goal cushion "
Annoyance
8.6%
"This is the weirdest 4-1 score line I’ve seen in a 1st half.
(Bloody hell boys, learn to finish please)."
Positive 17.1%
Neutral 31.7%
Negative 51.2%
Here's the thing — Everton fans weren't actually fixated on O'Brien's form in this conversation; instead, they were split between begrudging respect for an opponent's dribbling skills and frustration at their own players' decision-making, particularly Sarr's wayward touch. The bulk of the reaction was oddly neutral, almost detached, which tells you that for many Blues supporters watching this draw, the individual performances barely registered compared to the broader disappointment of dropping points at home. What annoyance did bubble up centred on basic errors and tactical confusion — the sense that Everton's attacking players weren't executing the fundamentals, rather than any debate about one player's confidence or decline.
Neutral
75.0%
"He certainly brought the dribbling boots, my word he makes it look easy "
Annoyance
14.3%
"is Sarr fucking blind? This guy keeps misjudging the ball today"
Confusion
10.7%
"Try turning him into a "Inzaghi" type, he is not a winger because he can't dribble. But he has s decent eye for goal."
Positive 11.8%
Neutral 50.0%
Negative 38.2%
Everton fans were largely content with James Tarkowski's display against Crystal Palace, but the broader defensive picture had them fuming—they're now openly demanding a summer rebuild around him as their only reliable centre-back, with several posting that starting next season with either Keane or the current backline options would be a genuine sign the club isn't serious about competing. There's a real sense that Tarkowski's individual brilliance is masking a systemic problem at the back, and patience has run out for band-aid solutions heading into the off-season.
Neutral
77.8%
"Tarky's been so good this half"
Desire
11.1%
"Absolute clown show at the back we need a reset, OB to CB, look at others to play beside him before Branth comes back."
Annoyance
11.1%
"If either of Keane or Tarkowski start the first match next season, we aren’t a serious club.
No coincidence we start leaking goals when Branthwaite g"
Positive 12.1%
Neutral 51.5%
Negative 36.4%
Crystal Palace supporters were left genuinely bewildered by the chances that slipped through their fingers during this two-all draw, with that resigned, almost melancholic tone of a side that knows exactly what they've missed. The emotion wasn't anger so much as wistful disbelief — there's a fatalism creeping in, a sense that victory was right there for the taking but somehow escaped them, and fans could only watch on thinking about what might have been rather than celebrating what actually was.
Neutral
82.1%
"That would have been sweet..."
Curiosity
10.7%
"Fuck me how was there not a goal then??"
Joy
7.1%
"It was nice to dream for a bit "
Positive 10.0%
Neutral 63.3%
Negative 26.7%
Right, so here's the thing—Tim produced an absolute masterclass in contradiction during this match. Fans were caught between genuine admiration for a crucial tackle and outright hilarity at a catastrophically bad striker, so much so that they couldn't decide whether to praise his defending or laugh themselves hoarse at his finishing. The humour was the throughline, but it came wrapped in real respect for moments when it mattered.
Neutral
54.2%
"Jesus, great tackle Tim"
Amusement
29.2%
"I cannot remember a striker of the ball worse than Tim hahahaha "
Admiration
16.7%
"Jesus, great tackle Tim"
Positive 37.9%
Neutral 13.8%
Negative 48.3%
Here's the thing: fans from both sides walked away from this one genuinely conflicted, because while most could appreciate a competitive, well-matched contest between two fairly evenly-balanced teams, that underlying frustration kept creeping in — Everton especially felt they should've been further ahead given the quality of their chances, which meant this draw felt more like points dropped than points earned. The neutrality in the reactions tells you everything you need to know: this wasn't controversial in a dramatic sense, it was just a game where neither side could quite finish the job, leaving supporters resigned but not entirely bitter about what they'd witnessed.
Neutral
43.8%
"A decent game from two teams who are quite equal, really. "
Admiration
37.5%
"Good game that. "
Annoyance
18.8%
"Fuckin nap that, we don’t deserve fuck all "
Positive 6.9%
Neutral 3.4%
Negative 89.7%
Palace fans are caught between recognising their attacking threat and absolute fury at a defensive collapse that's cost them six points in four weeks — right when the season still hung in the balance. There's a gnawing sense that fatigue and poor substitution timing have drained the fight from a team that looked capable when firing on all cylinders, leaving supporters frustrated at squandered opportunity rather than outright anger at the players themselves. The disappointment cuts deeper because they know they've got the quality; they just can't keep it together when it matters most.
Neutral
50.0%
"We are a decent attacking team when everyone is switched on."
Disappointment
35.0%
"This is pathetic now. No drive at all. Our subs destroy momentum, whether it is a timing thing or a quality thing. Skilli has had a dreadful 2nd half "
Annoyance
15.0%
"What the fuck has been up with our defending recently? That's piss poor"
Positive 37.9%
Neutral 62.1%
Negative 0.0%
Here is the thing — fans were absolutely clinical in their reactions to what unfolded in the second half, because this match turned into a proper four-goal spectacle. The emotional temperature stayed remarkably measured across the board, with nearly eighty per cent of discussion staying factual and matter-of-fact, but when admiration did break through, it was focused on the sharpness of Everton's attacking play — particularly Beto's movement and composure after Tarkowski's incisive pass. What you're seeing here is less raw passion and more analytical appreciation for the quality of football on display, which actually tells you something important: this draw felt earned on both sides, not like a missed opportunity or a defensive catastrophe.
Neutral
79.3%
"The perfect start to the second half! 🙌
Beto races onto Tarkowski's ball, beats Lacroix to it, turns him and puts it through Henderson's legs. UTT!!!"
Approval
13.8%
"The perfect start to the second half! 🙌
Beto races onto Tarkowski's ball, beats Lacroix to it, turns him and puts it through Henderson's legs. UTT!!!"
Admiration
6.9%
"Oh great a sub after 90"
Positive 7.1%
Neutral 14.3%
Negative 78.6%
Crystal Palace fans are caught between despair and defiance after a draw that felt like a loss. Two glaring missed chances in quick succession—the kind that should have put the match beyond Everton—have left the Palace faithful furious; this is the recurring nightmare of their season, where they create the chances but somehow can't finish what they've started. For a team sitting 14th and clawing for every point, squandering opportunities like that isn't just frustrating—it's the difference between survival and a relegation scrap come August.
Neutral
47.4%
"Let’s be brave today, no regrets, if we’re not up for this then just forget if "
Disappointment
31.6%
"I despair. I give up. "
Annoyance
21.1%
"Also the 2 fluffed chances in a minute very infuriating"
Positive 25.9%
Neutral 63.0%
Negative 11.1%
Everton fans absolutely erupted when James Tarkowski smashed them ahead in the sixth minute — this was the statement they needed after a rocky campaign, and here was their rock-solid centre-back delivering the goods early. But here is the thing: that early momentum would become the story of this entire match, because Palace had other ideas, and what unfolded over the next seventy minutes was a masterclass in never-say-die football that left Everton supporters watching their lead evaporate not once, but twice.
Neutral
85.2%
"TARKY!!!!!! 💪
[0-1] #CRYEVE https://t.co/qK9bF6GXQ9"
Anger
11.1%
"Big fucking B!!!!! Get in son!!!!"
Disappointment
3.7%
"And we still can't even get into it!"
Positive 17.4%
Neutral 47.8%
Negative 34.8%
Here's the thing: Everton fans were caught between cautious optimism and genuine anxiety. On one hand, seeing Beto and Dominic Calvert-Lewin actually firing together felt like a dream after years of striker chaos, and that relief came through in the posts — but the moment they looked at the bench, reality crashed back down. With Branthwaite sidelined, Grealish injured, and Gana unavailable, David Moyes is essentially working with a skeleton crew, and fans know one or two more injuries could turn this season into a complete disaster.
Neutral
82.4%
"Comms just said we have **two strikers in fine form ….** i’ve dreamed of times like this"
Sadness
11.8%
"Probably nobody seeing as Martinez plays for Villa"
Annoyance
5.9%
"Everton without Idrissa Gueye is so shit. We really need a better backup for him than Tim Iroegbunam"
Positive 31.8%
Neutral 22.7%
Negative 45.5%
Everton supporters couldn't help themselves — they were genuinely in awe of Jordan Pickford's distribution, with fans repeatedly calling it "elite" and "best in the world," showing real appreciation for a goalkeeper who's become a genuine threat from the back. What's telling is that even in a match that finished 2-2, this one moment of technical brilliance cut through the noise, with supporters actively hoping someone had captured it on film so they could relive it. That's the thing about Pickford — whether it's a save or a throw that finds its target perfectly, he's become the kind of player Everton fans celebrate in isolation, and on this afternoon at least, that admiration drowned out any frustration from dropping points.
Admiration
42.9%
"That was elite by Pickford, best in the world "
Neutral
35.7%
"That was elite by Pickford, best in the world "
Anger
21.4%
"I despise Jordan Pickford. Excellent goalkeeper, but my god he comes across as such a prick."
Positive 15.0%
Neutral 35.0%
Negative 50.0%
Crystal Palace fans are split on what their attacking options are actually worth in the market, and here's the thing — they're trying to figure out whether confidence is the missing ingredient or whether they've simply backed the wrong horses. Nketiah's getting credit for his cup contributions while Johnson's catching flak for inconsistency, yet there's a pocket of optimism suggesting that a couple of goals could flip the narrative entirely. The real tension is this: if lower sides are throwing serious money at players like Broja, why aren't Palace getting better value for their own attacking talent?
Neutral
66.7%
"Nketiah made a significant contribution to our FA Cup run last year.
Can't say the same for Johson and our UECL run this year."
Optimism
20.0%
"I do think that once Johnson gets a couple of goals his confidence will increase and he will improve. He had an okay game today even if he didn't set "
Realization
13.3%
"Nketiah made a significant contribution to our FA Cup run last year.
Can't say the same for Johson and our UECL run this year."
Everton supporters are lavishing praise on Jordan Pickford's remarkable throw from his own area that travelled deep into Crystal Palace's half, with several comparing it to a potential assist and debating his credentials as England's number one goalkeeper. The discussion centres on the technical brilliance of the distribution rather than controversial decision-making, showcasing fan appreciation for Pickford's increasingly important role in Everton's attacking build-up play.
Talent Can't Hide His Arrogance
Fans acknowledge Pickford's world-class ability between the sticks but can't stand his personality, viewing his behaviour as arrogant and unprofessional both on and off the pitch.
anger
Dean Henderson
Walter Benítez
"I despise Jordan Pickford. Excellent goalkeeper, but my god he comes across as such a prick."
"Pickford motm even though a few were straight at him he had to deal with them, hate that guy"
Pickford Is Simply the Best
Everton supporters celebrate their keeper as elite, potentially the world's finest, and treat his standout moments as evidence of his exceptional quality.
admiration
Jordan Pickford
Mark Travers
"Pickford! Bless that man. "
"That was elite by Pickford, best in the world "
Pickford Does Pickford Things
Neutral observers simply react to the moment itself—bemused, entertained, or baffled by his unpredictable decision-making without taking a stance on his character or ability.
neutral
Jordan Pickford
Mark Travers
"Good lord what a throw Pickford "
"Hahaha why in the fuck was Pickford out there"
Fans are divided on whether the draw represents a fair result, with Palace supporters frustrated they didn't capitalise on clear early dominance and squandered what should have been a comfortable lead. The overwhelming sentiment is one of underperformance and wasted opportunity—particularly the feeling that allowing Everton back into the match cost them what should have been victory.
We Should've Won That
Fans convinced their team squandered a dominant position and left points on the table through poor execution or mental fragility when the game was there to be won.
annoyance
Dwight McNeil
Beto
"Fuckin nap that, we don’t deserve fuck all "
"idk how to feel about that right now. Should probably have been further ahead in the first half, but felt we were lucky to hold on in the end. Underwhelming to say the least."
Entertainment Over the Result
Supporters celebrating the quality of football on show and accepting a draw as a fair reflection of a competitive, open match where chances went begging on both sides.
admiration
Dwight McNeil
Beto
"Good game that. "
"Thoroughly entertaining game of football. Probably a fair result we both missed good chances. Reckon if we play like that against rayo we’d win "
The Glass Half-Empty Analysis
Pragmatists breaking down exactly how the team bottled a winning position, combining frustration with tactical assessment to diagnose what went wrong in real time.
"It should've been 3-0 us after 20mins.
We somehow barely held onto a 2-2 draw.
They're not mentally up to it."
"idk how to feel about that right now. Should probably have been further ahead in the first half, but felt we were lucky to hold on in the end. Underwhelming to say the least."
Context Is Everything
Measured voices weighing the draw against pre-match expectations and broader circumstances like refereeing decisions, rather than judging the result in isolation.
neutral
Dwight McNeil
Beto
"Good half, but we should definitely be in the lead. We've had the better chances."
"That was a great point, I would absolutely have taken a draw before the game.
Reffing was awful though, it looked like there should have been at least 2 penalties"
Supporters are intensely debating Beto's performance and contribution during Everton's 2-2 draw with Crystal Palace, with particular focus on his defensive positioning and work rate compared to a teammate (referred to as "Barry" in posts). The discussion reveals frustration over inconsistent individual performances and suggests concerns about tactical shape and ball retention when certain players are on the pitch.
The Play-By-Play Observers
These fans are calling out specific moments — the good runs, the sloppy positioning, the substitution choices — because they're analysing what actually happened on the pitch.
neutral
Jordan Pickford
Mark Travers
"Myko mate please never do that again"
"Barry just looks lazy compared to Beto. Walking in offsides position is so infuriating."
Barry's The Problem Merchants
Convinced that Barry's work rate and tactical fit are dragging Everton down, they're furious at the team selection and demanding better from the substitute.
anger
Barry
"Barry is the worst fitting sub in this situation. Please no"
"@Everton Disappointing yet again Everton, sloppy in front of goal and poor defending. Don’t understand the Beto off Barry on routine, Barry offers nothing"
Beto's Brilliant Backers
They're watching Beto glide through defences with perfectly-timed through balls and wonder why anyone would ever take him off the pitch.
admiration
Jordan Pickford
Mark Travers
"Betos runs are really good, the though ball is on time and time again."
"Wow it looks even better in slow-motion from Beto"
The Season-Long Reckoners
Looking past the 2-2 draw itself, they're weighing up whether Beto's overall contribution this season justifies his place and questioning whether effort levels match the stakes.
"Beto has been fantastic at the back of this season"
"Barry only cared against city because it helped Arsenal. He can fuck off if he isnt going to put in a shift."
Fans are fixating on the apparent lack of broadcast attention given to Jean-Philippe Mateta's crucial 77th-minute equaliser in a thrilling 2-2 draw, with supporters joking that Sky Sports commentators seemed to have "fallen asleep" during the goal. The discussion also touches on individual performances, including Ismaïla Sarr's earlier equaliser and broader squad frustrations, but the core reaction centres on the bizarre disconnect between the match drama and the commentary coverage.
The Tactical Dissection Crew
These fans are breaking down the match moment by moment, focusing on how Everton's defensive lapses allowed Palace back in — clinical analysis without the emotion.
neutral
Sarr
Nathaniel Clyne
"@CPFC A really lousy goal to give away"
"@CPFC once again shows how bad the conference league is"
The Euphoria Brigade
They're living for Mateta's leveller and the resilience it showed, riding high on the belief that Palace can compete with anyone and already looking ahead to the next fixture.
admiration
approval
Sarr
Nathaniel Clyne
"@CPFC We’re thrilled to support Crystal Palace and can’t wait to see you shine in Manchester on Wednesday! We’re hyping up the May 13 clash in Manchester—betting on an epic showdow"
"@CPFC That's great so welcome to second half team"
The Wry Observers
They're laughing at the absurdity of it all — missing commentary, players who can't seem to find the net, the chaos of a 2-2 draw that could've gone either way.
"No commentary on matetas scoring?😂"
"Poor adam wharton is never gonna score lmao"
The Fury Faction
They're disgusted by Palace's defensive vulnerability and the pattern of gifting goals away, convinced the team's inconsistency is the real problem holding them back.
Sarr
Nathaniel Clyne
"@CPFC Another lousy goal to give away 🤬🤬"
"@CPFC Our league form is disgraceful."
Everton supporters are divided over David Moyes' management after a 2-2 draw with Crystal Palace, with critics arguing he switches to defensive mode when ahead and repeatedly fails to see out leads, whilst defenders maintain he's done solid work rebuilding the squad and blame the lack of striking depth and right-back options for Everton's inability to convert dominance into wins.
Gutted, Furious, Done Talking
These fans have reached breaking point — they're screaming into the void about bottled leads and wasted opportunities because Everton simply cannot see out matches when it matters.
disappointment
annoyance
season
moyes
"@Everton Why can’t we fucking win when it matters the most! So fucking tired of this shit."
"@Everton you gonna post the highlights all week again? fucking shite bottlers"
The Europa League That Got Away
This group remembers the Chelsea demolition and genuinely believed European football was coming, but now they're dissecting how Everton's inability to kill off matches has sabotaged their top-six hopes.
"Fraudulent title race arsenal were thrust into by referees and terrible for the premier league brand with their turgid football."
"When Everton beat Chelsea 3-0, I fancied them to make Europe but they just haven't been able to see out leads and conceded so many late goals. Missed opportunity for them this seas"
Pure Rage, No Filter
These supporters aren't analysing tactics or context — they're venting raw anger at what they see as a tinpot, useless club that consistently finds new ways to throw points away.
neutral
season
moyes
"@JordanCpimid @Everton you happy with that? Thats one of the worst results of our season. Embarrassing tinpot club"
"@Everton Another text book performance on how to piss 3 points up the wall!
Fuck off Everton, useless shower of twats!"
Fraudulent Title Contenders
This camp is stepping back from Everton's chaos to argue that Arsenal's title push is artificially propped up by referees while questioning the competitive integrity of the entire league.
"Fraudulent title race arsenal were thrust into by referees and terrible for the premier league brand with their turgid football."
"When Everton beat Chelsea 3-0, I fancied them to make Europe but they just haven't been able to see out leads and conceded so many late goals. Missed opportunity for them this seas"
Hope Against the Odds
A small but vocal group celebrating the early Tarkowski goal and still desperately clinging to the belief that pride and winning performances might be possible under Moyes.
season
moyes
"@Everton Cant wait for the day I can be proud of this team!"
"@Everton TARKS YOU BEAUTY! Early lead away, let's build on this!"
Crystal Palace supporters are furious at their side's profligacy in front of goal, insisting they should have won comfortably after 21 shots and controlling the second half, whilst also highlighting a glaring missed penalty that would have changed the match. Meanwhile, Everton fans are equally critical of their own performance, suggesting they were fortunate to escape with a point against a side they consider inferior on the day.
Everton's Self-Sabotage Never Ends
These fans are furious that Everton's defence fell apart yet again, squandering a chance to hold on despite Palace's dominance, cementing the view that the Blues are their own worst enemy.
disappointment
Séamus Coleman
Michael Keane
"@Everton Fucking joke of a club they do it to us everytime just fucking hold on the defence is so fucking shit and disorganised get rid of them all and get new ones in because this"
"@Everton Embarrassing stuff. Palace aren't arsed at all and we still collapse."
Palace Bottled An Easy Win
Neutral observers acknowledge that Crystal Palace created enough clear-cut chances — sitters, the woodwork, even a stonewall penalty shout — to have won comfortably, making the draw feel like a missed opportunity.
"How Palace didn't win that is beyond me. Missing sitters again, hitting the post. The most blatant penalty you are ever going to see. 21 shots and dominated the 2nd half."
"Everton defenders were in slow motion mode for the 2nd Palace goal."
Accepting The Draw As Reality
Pragmatic supporters see the 2-2 as a fair result given Palace's superior play, while already mentally moving on to what next season might bring.
neutral
Séamus Coleman
Michael Keane
"Oh yeah, I forgot about that.
Unrelated, but I'd love to see Palace win here."
"Road supporters never fail to give me chills "
A Point Earned, Season Already Over
Positive voices from both camps frame the draw as respectable — particularly for Everton given Palace's chances — with several fans already resigned to the campaign being a wash and eyeing future ambitions.
Séamus Coleman
Michael Keane
"Best fans in the world "
"Draw seems fair to be honest. Palace created much more chances. I'm already looking forward to next season at this point. Good luck to Palace in the final"
Everton supporters are concerned about Jake O'Brien's recent loss of finishing quality and self-belief, with many suggesting he has forgotten how to shoot consistently and appears mentally affected by missing chances he would normally convert. Fans debate whether tactical repositioning or simply regaining confidence might solve his struggles, with some attributing his decline to fatigue following his AFCON absence.
He's Lost The Plot
Fans venting pure frustration at O'Brien's inability to read the game and execute the basics — this is annoyance boiling over from consistent underperformance.
annoyance
missed
instagram
"is Sarr fucking blind? This guy keeps misjudging the ball today"
"Pretty horrible game from O'Brien today"
Work In Progress, Give Him Time
The patient camp arguing O'Brien's inexperience explains his struggles and that he showed glimpses of competence in the physical side of the game today.
neutral
missed
instagram
"Canvot is great on the ball. He’s just inexperienced. He’d played less than 13 professional matches when we got him. Marc going has a been a real crash course in turning him into a"
"He did ok today , won some aerial duals, got some tackles in, took the ball up field in the last minute there."
Wrong Position, Right Talent
Tactical critics who reckon O'Brien's got potential but he's being shoehorned into a role that doesn't suit his actual skillset or attributes.
"Try turning him into a "Inzaghi" type, he is not a winger because he can't dribble. But he has s decent eye for goal."
"Illimans forgotten how to shoot the last few weeks"
Can't Miss The Obvious Decline
Observers clocking that O'Brien's once-present shooting ability and decision-making have visibly deteriorated over recent weeks — something's genuinely gone backwards.
"Try turning him into a "Inzaghi" type, he is not a winger because he can't dribble. But he has s decent eye for goal."
"Illimans forgotten how to shoot the last few weeks"
Proof He's Turning A Corner
Optimists spotting real improvement in his technical quality and application today, arguing the doubters need to recognise when he actually gets it right.
missed
instagram
"His passing was about 10 times better today. I'm really rooting for him, especially as there's clear affection for him amongst the squad. I really hope he can find his form for us "
"He certainly brought the dribbling boots, my word he makes it look easy "
Fans reacted to the frantic 2-2 finish with a mix of frustration, dark humour, and philosophical resignation, as both sides surrendered leads in what became a chaotic encounter. The discussion oscillated between venting exasperation at their team's inability to hold control and finding levity in the absurdity of the result.
Draw That Defines the Season
Fans treating the 2-2 result as a pivotal moment that sums up their side's inconsistency and struggle to close out matches when it matters most.
neutral
"✊💙 https://t.co/XVL0WCqsr4"
"FUCK THAT WAS IT "
Complete Tactical Collapse
Supporters furious at defensive breakdowns and lack of control in a game that should have been won, blaming poor organisation and individual errors throughout.
anger
"That was so so fucking shit"
"So, so poor. Jesus Christ."
Resilience and Points on the Board
Believers in their team's character and fighting spirit, celebrating the comeback and the refusal to surrender despite going behind, seeing moral victory in the draw.
approval
"GOD loves us all so much he sent his one and only son to die for our sins ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤"
"Yeah I think you nailed it "
Supporters heavily discussed David Moyes's attacking changes late in the 2-2 draw, particularly the introduction of Tyrique George and removal of Merlin Röhl, with opinion split on whether Röhl should have stayed on given his creative contribution and whether George or Iliman Ndiaye should have been withdrawn instead. Fitness concerns about George's limited minutes this season and questions about his defensive capabilities featured alongside praise for Röhl's energy and chance creation before his exit.
The McNeil Efficiency Question
Everton fans examining whether McNeil and Gana are genuinely creating attacking threats or merely occupying space without real impact.
neutral
Dwight McNeil
Beto
"They are. Gana and Dwight are no where close to impactful on offense as those two "
"Rohl is hardly out of position on the wing, though, and got torched defensively when he was covering at RB. Not to mention George being a downgrade from Rohl on the wing. One of ou"
The Rohl Redemption Arc
True believers convinced that Rohl's all-action performances on both flanks prove he deserves consistent starts and that benching him has been criminal mismanagement.
admiration
love
Dwight McNeil
Beto
"Rohl is so good man, plus his hair is glorious"
"I have been really impressed with Rohl on both parts of the pitch. Really happy he is taking his chance with the opportunity."
The Tactical Shuffle Reality
Pragmatists tracking how substitutions actually unfolded in real time and suggesting fresh lineups might unlock better balance for the next match.
"Next game start George and Rohl, let Illy come on against tired legs and get his mojo back "
"Forgot George was on "
Rohl's Frustrating Inconsistency
Sceptics arguing that despite flashes of quality, Rohl's erratic presence and defensive vulnerabilities make him too unreliable to build around week to week.
Dwight McNeil
Beto
Iliman Ndiaye
"Rohl rotting on the bench for so long has been a disgrace and I will never stop complaining about it"
"Rohl is bloody everywhere I swear"
Everton supporters are grappling with the near-certainty that their season won't end in European qualification after drawing 2-2 with Crystal Palace, with fans debating whether the team's defensive frailties and inability to kill off opponents means they don't deserve continental football anyway. There's frustration over refereeing decisions, recognition that squad depth isn't good enough, and a resigned acceptance that a top-ten finish is the realistic goal for this campaign.
Defence and Discipline Killed Us
These fans believe Everton threw away a genuine European chance through sloppy defending and lazy mistakes, arguing the players simply didn't show enough hunger to earn a top-six finish.
disappointment
Séamus Coleman
Michael Keane
James Tarkowski
"We don’t deserve Europe, they could have scored 4 or 5 today, recently our defence has been shambolic, the midfield looked lost at times defensively "
"so many stupid mistakes and lazy errors. Players don’t WANT to make Europe then we don’t deserve it"
The Europa League Dream Is Dead
These supporters are accepting the harsh reality that a 10th-place finish is now the realistic outcome, and they're moving past the disappointment to face facts.
neutral
Séamus Coleman
Michael Keane
"That's the end of Europe. People can complain about the quality of the centre forwards but they will not be the reason we miss out. 16 non penalty goals in their last 22 games. A r"
"10th place finish it is boys!"
We're Just Not Built for This Yet
This camp acknowledges structural weaknesses — squad depth, striker quality, defensive vulnerabilities — and points to refereeing decisions as additional factors that cost Everton critical points in the run-in.
"Squad depth is not strong enough for Europe & lots of mistakes by not killing off teams. Need striker left & right back in the summer"
"We need a neutral referee to be honest. With all those decisions Everton have been screwed out of the past few games, We'd already be IN the Europe picture."
Next Season We'll Get It Right
These optimists see today's draw as a bump in the road and genuinely believe a sustained push next year will get Everton back into European contention or at least secure a comfortable top-half position.
optimism
Séamus Coleman
Michael Keane
"Cant wait for next year. I will be top 10 I promise."
"Top half would be fantastic from where we have been. Its still possible we finish 13th or 14th. "
Everton supporters are frustrated by the absence of key players — particularly Idrissa Gueye in midfield — and are questioning whether David Moyes has adequate depth to compete, though there is cautious optimism about having two strikers in form. The broader concern centres on whether the club's thin squad can sustain a challenge as injuries pile up.
Beto's Finally Here
Fans seeing genuine hope in Everton's striker form and believing the club has finally addressed its most glaring attacking weakness.
neutral
Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall
James Garner
"Now THAT is the type of striker we need."
"suddenly I trust in our striker signings"
Threadbare and Furious
Supporters venting their frustration at being forced to field a squad so thin on depth that Moyes has no decent backup options anywhere.
sadness
annoyance
Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall
James Garner
Tim Iroegbunam
"Everton without Idrissa Gueye is so shit. We really need a better backup for him than Tim Iroegbunam"
"Why would you move arguably our brightest attacker over the last 2 matches deeper? Iro is not a right back in the slightest. He is “sound defensively” in that he runs around and wi"
Tactical Triage in Crisis
Analysts pointing out that even when tactics work, Moyes is operating with such limited personnel that squad management becomes an impossible puzzle.
"Probably nobody seeing as Martinez plays for Villa"
"Look at our bench today, who's our options?
Moyes is working with a paper thin squad with Graelish, Brantwaite, and Gana gueye being out "
Match Events, Blunt Reactions
Fans simply processing what happened on the pitch without looking past the immediate 2-2 result to bigger systemic problems.
"Probably nobody seeing as Martinez plays for Villa"
"Look at our bench today, who's our options?
Moyes is working with a paper thin squad with Graelish, Brantwaite, and Gana gueye being out "
Strikers in Sync, Dreams Realised
Optimists daring to believe that having two forwards performing at the same time is the breakthrough moment Everton's season desperately needed.
Dwight McNeil
Beto
Iliman Ndiaye
"Congrats! Can she play right back? "
"Comms just said we have **two strikers in fine form ….** i’ve dreamed of times like this"
Fans are frustratingly dissecting a sequence of moments where Crystal Palace failed to capitalise on attacking opportunities and collectively struggled to clear defensive danger, with multiple posts criticising both the execution of chances and the passivity of defenders who watched danger unfold rather than intervening. The neutral sentiment reflects disappointment at individual and collective errors rather than outright anger—a sense that the result slipped away through avoidable mistakes.
The Realistic Diagnostician
Fans acknowledging the lucky escape or poor execution without drama—they see what happened on the pitch and call it straight.
neutral
"Lucky getting away with that one for me"
"Ok that was not the best shot."
The Rage-Fuelled Believer
Supporters absolutely wound up that Palace didn't punish Everton's mistake, channelling frustration at wasted opportunity into expletive-laden fury.
"Fuck me how was there not a goal then??"
"Surprised we got away with that one "
The Dreamer's Lament
Fans savouring the brief moment of what-could-have-been before reality crashed back down, mourning the goal that nearly was.
joy
"It was nice to dream for a bit "
"That would have been sweet..."
Everton supporters are united in the view that James Tarkowski's decline in pace and positioning means he cannot be a regular starter next season, with calls for a defensive reset built around younger options like O'Brien and Branthwaite once fit. The consensus is bleak about the current bench quality, suggesting structural change is needed rather than minor tweaks.
Building Around Tarkowski's Foundation
These fans see Tarkowski as the reliable centre-back cornerstone and are focused on identifying the right defensive partners and signing the reinforcements—especially at right-back—needed to compete properly next season.
neutral
Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall
James Garner
"Yes. They are both good at supporting and covering space. They both need to be paired with a close out/ speedy type Centerback.
It bums me out when this sub goes in on Tarkowski "
"I definitely agree a RB is a must and then O’Brien can be great competition for Tarkys spot."
Branthwaite Injury Exposes Fatal Weakness
These supporters are furious that Everton's defensive injury crisis has forced them to field fourth-choice centre-backs, and they're demanding a complete squad overhaul as proof the club is serious about top-flight ambitions.
annoyance
Dwight McNeil
Beto
Iliman Ndiaye
"The worst loss of the derby was the Branthwaite injury. Without a RB, it means we're using our 4th choice CB."
"If either of Keane or Tarkowski start the first match next season, we aren’t a serious club.
No coincidence we start leaking goals when Branthwaite goes down. I’m fucking sick of "
Tarkowski Saving Us Right Now
These fans are celebrating Tarkowski's individual performance in the moment, recognising his commanding display as exactly the kind of leadership the defence desperately needs on the pitch.
Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall
James Garner
"Tarky's been so good this half"
"Tarks been huge this game "
Fans from both sides are nervously anticipating a potential last-minute goal in stoppage time, with some expressing frustration at missed finishing chances throughout the match. The tension reflects a pattern of both teams either conceding or failing to convert late opportunities, leaving supporters anxiously waiting for the final whistle.
Live-Action Commentary Mode
Fans narrating the match in real time, absorbed by the ebb and flow of play and waiting to see who'll seize the moment next.
neutral
"God damn one of you have a pop"
"I feel we have another goal in us tbh"
We're Writing The Script
Believers convinced their side has momentum and another goal in them, riding the emotional high of a contested match.
"I can feel it, our winner "
"Good start. But it's important we score when we're up. "
This Should Be Buried By Now
Frustrated supporters watching their team create chances but lack the clinical finishing to put the game to bed when it matters.
annoyance
"This is the weirdest 4-1 score line I’ve seen in a 1st half.
(Bloody hell boys, learn to finish please)."
"Fuck me this finishing"
Crystal Palace supporters are venting their frustration at a player identified as KDH (likely a defender or midfielder) for a disastrous performance featuring multiple costly missed chances and poor finishing, with fans torn between anger at his profligacy and confusion over potential offside decisions. The consensus is damning: KDH has delivered one of the worst individual displays of the season, with his wastefulness directly contributing to Palace's inability to capitalise on attacking opportunities during this chaotic 2-2 draw.
KDH's Clinical Finishing Has Completely Collapsed
Palace fans are absolutely seething that their forward has squandered multiple one-on-one opportunities when the match was there to be won.
anger
disappointment
Jordan Pickford
Mark Travers
"Jesus fucking Christ KDH’s one on ones are awful"
"Kdh has been having an absolute stinker holy fuck"
Creating Gold But Finishing Fool's Gold
This camp acknowledges KDH's tireless work rate and chance creation on the break, but recognises his execution in front of goal is genuinely costing the team.
neutral
Jordan Pickford
Mark Travers
"To be fair to KDH, he’s creating so much on the break, sprinting box to box. He’s making the chances he’s missing."
"please............It's Keano time baby.......please"
Time To Bring In Keano
Frustrated supporters are calling for a substitution, desperate to see Keane enter the pitch and provide a fresh attacking option before the damage becomes permanent.
"please............It's Keano time baby.......please"
"Keano man"
The Effort Was There, Just Not The Precision
A small pocket of fans give KDH credit for his explosive pace and movement, even if the finishing let him down on the night.
Jordan Pickford
Mark Travers
"Did great with the burst if pace initially kdh.. over thunk it innthe end "
"He's making DCL's one on one skills look good."
Palace supporters are divided over the form and future of strikers Johnson and Nketiah, with many questioning whether the club's combined £65m investment in the pair represents poor business given injuries and a lack of goals. The consensus suggests both players have become depreciating assets, though some argue patience is warranted before writing them off entirely.
Johnson's A Lost Cause
Palace fans are furious that Johnson lacks the quality to justify keeping him, arguing Nketiah is the far superior asset worth fighting to retain.
"Would rather keep nketiah. Johnson Looks so bad."
"Eddie Murphy has less value. If newly promoted Burnley can spend like 17 mil on Armando Broja then hopefully someone else is dumb enough to take a gamble on one of these bums. I wo"
Johnson Needs The Right System
Pragmatists reckon Johnson's still salvageable under proper coaching and tactical setup, so selling him cheaply would be a mistake when Nketiah could fetch decent money.
neutral
"Both are better value than this post. "
"We won’t get any money for Johnson, and I still feel like he can be fixed with the right coach and setup. Flog Nketiah just to get rid of his wages, no hope there.
As for who is w"
Fitness Trumps Potential
Realists back Johnson because he at least stays available and healthy, whereas Nketiah's injury record makes him an unreliable investment despite his talent.
"Johnson"
"Johnson for me. Eddie might not be able to stay fit but at least you know he’s on the field when he plays. "
Recent Form Tells The Story
Fans weighing the evidence point to Johnson's decent recent performances as proof he deserves time to build confidence and goal contributions.
"Johnson"
"Johnson for me. Eddie might not be able to stay fit but at least you know he’s on the field when he plays. "
Nketiah's Already Proven It
Optimists champion Nketiah for his tangible contributions to Palace's cup campaigns, proving his worth in the shirt when it matters most.
optimism
"Nketiah made a significant contribution to our FA Cup run last year.
Can't say the same for Johson and our UECL run this year."
"I do think that once Johnson gets a couple of goals his confidence will increase and he will improve. He had an okay game today even if he didn't set the world alight.
Nketiah jus"
Neutral observers and Everton supporters are expressing deep frustration with Michael Keane's performances at a critical stage of the season, with fans criticising his pace, positioning, and decision-making alongside centre-back partner James Tarkowski. The discourse suggests Keane's display has deteriorated noticeably following his contract extension, leaving supporters questioning whether his age and declining athleticism are now actively harming Everton's defensive stability.
Keane's Defensive Collapse Costs Points
Everton fans are furious that Michael Keane's poor individual performances are directly costing them goals and results in crucial fixtures.
annoyance
keane
Séamus Coleman
"@Everton Michael Keane has been absolute dog shit since coming on in the derby.
Costing us goals every match!"
"Keane just isn’t fucking good enough"
Championship Standard Just Isn't Good Enough
A more measured camp pointing out that Keane simply lacks the quality required to operate at Premier League level, with his weaknesses exposed repeatedly.
neutral
keane
Séamus Coleman
"@Everton Keane is championship quality at best"
"Michael Keane maybe?
Not really a comeback but Niasse saving Koeman's job (Bournemouth i think?) was fun."
Palace's Attack Thrived On Blue Confusion
A smaller group sarcastically crediting Keane and Tarkowski for essentially playing as an extra Palace attacking threat through their defensive errors.
keane
Séamus Coleman
"Tarks and Keane sleeping. Well done."
"@Everton Shoutout to Keane and tarkowski for their unreal work up front for palace too"
Everton supporters have launched a scathing attack on winger Iliman Ndiaye following his woeful performance in the 2-2 draw with Crystal Palace, with fans questioning his effort, finishing, and overall application since returning from the Africa Cup of Nations. The criticism ranges from accusations of laziness to suggestions he's deliberately underperforming to avoid summer transfer interest, as one of Everton's most important players this season produced arguably his worst showing in a Toffees shirt.
Ndiaye's Out of Form Nightmare
Fans demanding Everton cut their losses on a player who has become genuinely unplayable, delivering nothing in possession and vanishing when it matters most.
disappointment
annoyance
Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall
James Garner
"@Everton KDH and ndiaye once again the 2 worst players on the pitch. Time to cash out both wank"
"Ndiaye has been dreadful today, created nothing and constantly done nothing in possession. Probably worst 3 performances for us"
He's Still Got It Somewhere
Supporters defending Ndiaye's work rate and technical ability even on bad days, betting that his effort and dribbling will eventually click back into form.
neutral
Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall
James Garner
"Feels like it's ages since Ndiaye scored. Let's hope he's got his scoring boots on. "
"The good thing about Ndiaye is that even when he's shit he still dribble and press like a madman "
The Whole Squad's Let Us Down
Fans processing the draw as a collective failure where multiple underperformers—not just Ndiaye—have blown a chance to climb the table.
"O’Brien still not a fullback and another disappointing performance from N’Diaye… 🥱"
"Ndaiye and dbh had a stinker"
Harsh Criticism Misses the Point
A small camp arguing that comparisons to other players miss Ndiaye's actual contribution, finding redemption in his press and ball-carrying even when finishing falters.
Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall
James Garner
"@BallerTalk0 @Everton Rohl was better than Ndiaye today."
"The good thing about Ndiaye is that even when he's shit he still dribble and press like a madman "
Palace supporters are agonised by their inability to convert clear-cut opportunities into goals, with the team squandering chances to put the game beyond Everton and ultimately settling for a 2-2 draw when they desperately needed three points. The frustration reflects a broader pattern of tactical vulnerability and clinical finishing that's haunting their season in the battle to avoid the bottom half.
We Should've Buried Them
Crystal Palace fans furious that profligate finishing cost them a winnable game, hammering the recurring nightmare of creating chances without converting them.
disappointment
annoyance
"Also the 2 fluffed chances in a minute very infuriating"
"It's frustrating how much of a regular occurance this is becoming, absolutely dominating the game and not putting chances to bed, then we concede and shit the bed."
Clinical Teams Punish Our Mistakes
Tactical observers recognising that Everton capitalised on Palace's wastefulness, arguing the Eagles' failure to kill the game off handed momentum to their opponents.
"Right but you put those chances away and teams fall apart. We’re allowing teams confidence and opportunity. "
"How many fucking chances do we need"
The Story Of The Match
Supporters simply narrating what unfolded on the pitch — the chances missed, the goals conceded, the rollercoaster of a 2-2 draw.
"Right but you put those chances away and teams fall apart. We’re allowing teams confidence and opportunity. "
"How many fucking chances do we need"
Could've Gone Either Way
Pragmatists accepting the draw as the nature of football, crediting luck and thin margins rather than dwelling on what-ifs.
neutral
"Let’s be brave today, no regrets, if we’re not up for this then just forget if "
"Any other day we’d have had 4 or 5. Just needed a touch more luck to take our chances. It’s football, and we’ve done so much better than the last few seasons. Take a break from the"
We Dominated, That's Growth
Rare optimists framing Palace's attacking dominance and chances created as genuine progress, even if the points were shared.
"Any other day we’d have had 4 or 5. Just needed a touch more luck to take our chances. It’s football, and we’ve done so much better than the last few seasons. Take a break from the"
"Let’s be brave today, no regrets, if we’re not up for this then just forget if "
Crystal Palace supporters are furious with their team's defensive breakdown and physical exhaustion, particularly after conceding eight goals in their last three matches since an injury to a key player. Fans are pointing to a lack of squad rotation throughout the season as the root cause, leaving the side visibly depleted and unable to maintain the discipline that characterised their earlier form.
Palace's Defensive House Is Crumbling
Fans are furious at the team's inability to organise their backline, treating two-goal collapses as a symptom of structural breakdown rather than bad luck.
disappointment
annoyance
Séamus Coleman
Michael Keane
James Tarkowski
"What the fuck has been up with our defending recently? That's piss poor"
"This is pathetic now. No drive at all. Our subs destroy momentum, whether it is a timing thing or a quality thing. Skilli has had a dreadful 2nd half and should have been replaced "
Squad Depth Can't Handle the Fixture Pile-Up
Pragmatic observers believe Palace are being exposed by fixture congestion and threadbare options, and adding more midweek matches next season would be disastrous without reinforcements.
"Sitters missed and awful defending just dreadful all around really"
"You guys want to add *more* matches mid week next season?
Look at the squad....we've got what maybe 3 injuries right now of first team players?
Everyone has looked dead since the"
The Attacking Talent Is There—Just Needs Consistency
A small contingent sees flashes of genuine quality in Palace's offensive play, suggesting the problem is mentality and focus rather than ability.
Séamus Coleman
Michael Keane
"We are a decent attacking team when everyone is switched on."
"wow where has that been! looking world class all of a sudden"
Neutral observers and mixed supporters react with excitement to a frantic 2-2 draw at Selhurst Park, where Tarkowski's early Everton lead was cancelled out by Sarr's equaliser, Beto's second-half go-ahead, and Mateta's dramatic late leveller. The tone is celebratory chaos — fans and neutrals exclaiming at the pace of goals and the theatrical nature of the comeback, with particular focus on standout moments from Everton's defence and Palace's attacking resurgence.
Early Sucker Punch Reality Check
Everton fans reeling from Tarkowski's stunning sixth-minute opener, watching their side get caught cold and struggling to process the immediate damage.
neutral
"Get the fuck in"
"Get in Tarky!"
Everton Strike First Dominance
Everton supporters celebrating a dream start and early control, believing their side has seized the initiative exactly when it matters most.
"TARKY!!!!!! 💪
[0-1] #CRYEVE https://t.co/qK9bF6GXQ9"
"TARKY!!!!!! 💪
[0-1] #CRYEVE https://t.co/qK9bF6GXQ9"
Palace's Frustration Boils Over
Crystal Palace fans furious at falling behind early despite competitive play, seeing the goal as a gut punch that could cost them dearly in a tight midtable scrap.
anger
disappointment
"And we still can't even get into it!"
"Get the fuck in! What a start!!"
Cross-Cutting Patterns
Dwight McNeil
Appears across 4 debates: Palace and Everton Battle to Controversial 2-2 Draw, Everton Fans Demand Defensive Rebuild Around Tarkowski, Everton Fans Grapple With Squad Depth Issues, Everton Fans Debate Attacking Substitutions in Draw
Beto
Appears across 4 debates: Palace and Everton Battle to Controversial 2-2 Draw, Everton Fans Demand Defensive Rebuild Around Tarkowski, Everton Fans Grapple With Squad Depth Issues, Everton Fans Debate Attacking Substitutions in Draw
Séamus Coleman
Appears across 4 debates: Palace Collapse Blamed on Fatigue and Defensive Frailty, Palace Dominate But Squander Chances In Draw, Everton's European Dream Slips Away After Draw, Everton Fans Lose Faith in Keane's Defensive Form
Jordan Pickford
Appears across 3 debates: Fans Divided Over Beto's Impact After Palace Draw, Everton Fans Hail Pickford's Extraordinary Long-Range Throw, Palace Fans Fury at KDH's Missed Chances
Mark Travers
Appears across 3 debates: Fans Divided Over Beto's Impact After Palace Draw, Everton Fans Hail Pickford's Extraordinary Long-Range Throw, Palace Fans Fury at KDH's Missed Chances