EPL commentator & pundit discourse MW1 → MW34
How often football fans mention each commentator or pundit — and whether they speak well or ill of them. 186 taxonomy terms (personalities, plus meta tokens for "commentator", "pundit", on-screen graphics, etc.) matched across every post and reply in 2,681,883 Reddit, X/Twitter and YouTube comments. Every matching post scored by VADER (a lexicon + grammar sentiment model tuned for social-media text) on a −1…+1 compound axis: ≥+0.05 positive, ≤−0.05 negative, in-between neutral. Net sentiment = pos% − neg%.
Most mentioned
Gary Neville
6,407 posts · 6,747 occurrences
Fans' favourite (net sentiment, ≥100 scored posts)
Michail Antonio
+41.6 net · 178 posts · avg compound +0.290
Most disliked (lowest net, ≥100 scored posts)
Robbie Savage
-33.3 net · 138 posts · avg compound -0.124
29,311
Person mentions
distinct pundits: 89
13,341
Meta tokens (commentator, pundit, graphic…)
net sent. +8.1
186
Taxonomy terms
incl. aliases & nicknames
Caveats. Many terms are ambiguous — "dublin" (city / Dion Dublin), "henry" (Thierry Henry / anyone named Henry), "rio" (Rio Ferdinand / Rio de Janeiro / a car), "keane" (Roy Keane / Robbie Keane / Harry Kane phonetic), etc. Surname-only matches on ex-player pundits also pick up references to their playing days. VADER doesn't understand football context, so sarcasm, banter and emoji-only posts can push scores around. Treat the headline rankings as directional, not forensic.
Top terms by raw occurrences
Total times each taxonomy term appeared across the 2,681,883 posts (top 40 shown). Includes names, nicknames (e.g. carra, wrighty) and meta tokens (commentator, pundit, overlay). Multiple aliases for the same person (e.g. gary neville, neville, gnev) appear as separate rows here — the canonical view is below.
Ranked: commentators by net sentiment
"Favourite" isn't who is mentioned most — it's who carries the most positive balance of sentiment. Top 50 most-mentioned pundits (≥30 scored posts) ranked two ways below.
Most disliked (lowest net)
Sentiment breakdown — top 25 commentators by posts
For each commentator: share of their posts that are positive / neutral / negative, and the net (pos% − neg%). Scored posts only (VADER labels everything; the distribution for a given person is computed from posts that mention them).
| # | Commentator / Pundit | Posts | Occur. | Pos | Neu | Neg | Net | Distribution |
|---|
| 1 | Gary Neville | 6,407 | 6,747 | 39.7% | 23.3% | 37.0% | +2.8 | |
| 2 | Rio Ferdinand | 4,739 | 4,977 | 44.6% | 32.5% | 22.9% | +21.8 | |
| 3 | Steve Mcmanaman | 3,446 | 3,530 | 38.0% | 27.8% | 34.3% | +3.7 | |
| 4 | Roy Keane | 3,152 | 3,285 | 48.1% | 24.8% | 27.2% | +20.9 | |
| 5 | Jamie Carragher | 1,765 | 1,809 | 43.9% | 20.7% | 35.5% | +8.4 | |
| 6 | Paul Scholes | 720 | 742 | 47.9% | 21.7% | 30.4% | +17.5 | |
| 7 | Wayne Rooney | 703 | 728 | 51.9% | 26.0% | 22.0% | +29.9 | |
| 8 | Thierry Henry | 685 | 698 | 48.6% | 27.3% | 24.1% | +24.5 | |
| 9 | Daniel Sturridge | 625 | 638 | 47.4% | 25.9% | 26.7% | +20.6 | |
| 10 | Martin Tyler | 593 | 602 | 45.4% | 29.0% | 25.6% | +19.7 | |
| 11 | Lee Dixon | 459 | 464 | 24.8% | 27.5% | 47.7% | -22.9 | |
| 12 | Jamie Redknapp | 446 | 458 | 35.7% | 30.7% | 33.6% | +2.0 | |
| 13 | Gareth Bale | 398 | 403 | 46.5% | 36.4% | 17.1% | +29.4 | |
| 14 | Graham Potter | 395 | 398 | 37.0% | 27.8% | 35.2% | +1.8 | |
| 15 | Peter Drury | 356 | 361 | 36.0% | 30.6% | 33.4% | +2.5 | |
| 16 | Ally Mccoist | 300 | 302 | 37.0% | 24.0% | 39.0% | -2.0 | |
| 17 | Darren Fletcher | 273 | 280 | 41.0% | 29.7% | 29.3% | +11.7 | |
| 18 | Alan Shearer | 255 | 258 | 51.0% | 23.9% | 25.1% | +25.9 | |
| 19 | Keith Andrews | 235 | 236 | 53.6% | 19.1% | 27.2% | +26.4 | |
| 20 | Alan Smith | 218 | 219 | 34.9% | 27.1% | 38.1% | -3.2 | |
| 21 | Michail Antonio | 178 | 181 | 57.9% | 25.8% | 16.3% | +41.6 | |
| 22 | Alex Scott | 139 | 141 | 46.8% | 36.7% | 16.5% | +30.2 | |
| 23 | Robbie Savage | 138 | 139 | 31.2% | 4.3% | 64.5% | -33.3 | |
| 24 | Martin Keown | 117 | 117 | 51.3% | 13.7% | 35.0% | +16.2 | |
| 25 | Stephen Warnock | 116 | 119 | 25.9% | 32.8% | 41.4% | -15.5 | |
Share of commentator chatter — per matchweek
Number of posts per matchweek mentioning each of the top 5 commentators (plus meta "commentator/pundit/graphic" tokens). Good for spotting "which match made people talk about whom" — e.g. a Carragher punditry moment or a Neville hot take on Monday Night Football.
Net sentiment per matchweek — top 5
Weekly net sentiment (pos% − neg%) for each of the five most-mentioned pundits. Dips suggest a bad-take week; spikes suggest they called something right (or everyone's laughing with them).
Top raw terms
Frequency leaderboard for individual taxonomy tokens.
| # | Term | Occurrences | % | |
|---|
| 1 | commentator | 5,345 | 13.3% | |
| 2 | rio | 4,927 | 12.2% | |
| 3 | commentators | 4,816 | 11.9% | |
| 4 | neville | 3,878 | 9.6% | |
| 5 | macca | 3,465 | 8.6% | |
| 6 | gary neville | 2,765 | 6.9% | |
| 7 | keane | 2,377 | 5.9% | |
| 8 | pundits | 1,718 | 4.3% | |
| 9 | carragher | 1,111 | 2.8% | |
| 10 | pundit | 873 | 2.2% | |
| 11 | scholes | 607 | 1.5% | |
| 12 | roy keane | 595 | 1.5% | |
| 13 | henry | 591 | 1.5% | |
| 14 | sturridge | 580 | 1.4% | |
| 15 | rooney | 564 | 1.4% | |
| 16 | carra | 494 | 1.2% | |
| 17 | punditry | 403 | 1.0% | |
| 18 | graham potter | 398 | 1.0% | |
| 19 | lee dixon | 377 | 0.9% | |
| 20 | redknapp | 358 | 0.9% | |
Alias breakdown (top 12 persons)
Which tokens collapsed into each canonical commentator. Counts are raw occurrences of that alias.
| Canonical | Aliases (occurrences) |
|---|
| Gary Neville | neville·3,753, gary neville·2,556, g nev·66, gnev·32 |
| Rio Ferdinand | rio·4,689, rio ferdinand·50 |
| Steve Mcmanaman | macca·3,381, mcmanaman·48, steve mcmanaman·17 |
| Roy Keane | keane·2,265, roy keane·587, keano·300 |
| Jamie Carragher | carragher·1,084, carra·478, jamie carragher·203 |
| Paul Scholes | scholes·586, paul scholes·134 |
| Wayne Rooney | rooney·546, wayne rooney·134, wazza·23 |
| Thierry Henry | henry·578, thierry henry·107 |
| Daniel Sturridge | sturridge·567, daniel sturridge·58 |
| Martin Tyler | martin tyler·326, tyler·267 |
| Lee Dixon | lee dixon·375, dixon·84 |
| Jamie Redknapp | redknapp·347, jamie redknapp·99 |
Most positive / most negative posts per top commentator
Gary Neville 6,407 posts · net +2.8
Highest and lowest VADER-scoring posts mentioning Gary Neville. Compound range −1…+1.
Most positive
- MW2·FULMUN+1.00Please Please Please give Gary Neville a managerial job at Man Utd.....
Make Roy Keane Assistant Manager...
Just so Maguire can leak the team talk at half time and we can all have a good laugh watching it 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
- MW14·MUNWHU+1.00WHERES NEVILLE WHEN WEST HAM SCORE 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
- MW23·ARSMUN+1.00I feel like hes playing a bit of a mind game saying he should hand the baton over!!
However Ancelotti would be perfect at Manchester United, he prefers a 4-4-2 and a 4-3-3 and the way he sets up the wing backs and wingers would be a good fit.
Whoever it is, I can only echo Neville. I think because of UTD success other teams supporters think we can not take losing but the majority of supporters there around before the 1992 and waited 25 years for that success. As a supporter I just want to see desire, passion, fight (this DNA they talk about.) For me though entertaining, I can take losing and want to win every match but if they put a shift in and the better team won or was just unlu...
Most negative
- MW29·NEWMUN-0.98GOLD OF THE SEASON....ALL THE refff have a eye problem 😂😅😅.....well deserve Win...Gary Neville....N CO 😢😢😢😢😢 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭....
- MW32·MUNLEE-0.98Gary Neville needs to have a word with mates Carrick and Keane to explain the Martinez sending off. Hair pulls are straight red card offences for a reason. They are often picked up by VAR rather than the on field referee
Hair pulls are ugly offences and have no place in the beautiful game. They are straight red card offences not just for the optics or for legalistic reasons.
Crucially hair pulls have potential to cause serious injury. Hair pulls directly endanger the safety of the opponent by causing sudden, violent whiplash to the neck and head. Even if not a "punch," a purposeful yank is rightly deemed excessive force and a violent act for good reason. Players and managers kn...
- MW28·ARSCHE-0.98Why do we always play to the level of our opposition?!? Chelsea are clearly rubbish, despite Neville wanking himself off over every thing they do, and yet we’ve decided to play equally bad and forgotten how to do anything even at a basic level, like passing to feet, and not passing to players surrounded or behind a Chelsea player.
It’s infuriating because even when we have an off day we don’t drop our whole level as a team, but that’s what we’ve been doing for the past few months. Haven’t looked decent this calendar year, with the exception of Villa, and that was in part because they were abject that day.
I have so much sympathy for Arteta because he can only tell them so much and the...
Rio Ferdinand 4,739 posts · net +21.8
Highest and lowest VADER-scoring posts mentioning Rio Ferdinand. Compound range −1…+1.
Most positive
- MW27·NFOLIV+1.00Rio was amazing 🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤
- MW4·BURLIV+1.00Couple notes from Burnley game
1. Everyone talked last season about Arne Slot needing adaptation high. Last season he took the squad to the prem but this season we have new players, new tactics and everyone wants everything to be perfect right away. 4 bloody games in, give the team some time to gel.
2. Adding onto this idea, we must keep in mind Diogo Jota's passing (Rest in peace), and the impact it would of had on the squad. One of their work colleagues but also a great friend who they see probably more than their family. Especially with Mo as we have seen his struggles, that needs to be taken into account.
3. Isak will be welcomed, so many crosses from us into a box with none ...
- MW30·LIVTOT+1.00I’ve avoided being Slot out all season long but been worn down match by match. I just can’t with it anymore. The players need to cop some responsibility for sure but the system and the tactics are not working.
Wirtz is our best playmaker but somehow keeps finding himself isolated as the furthest man forward in the box. He needs to take more shots on than he does and that is a him thing, but he shouldn’t be pressed so high when he is the one meant to be pulling strings.
Szobo is a CM, not a RB. Yes, he can play on the right, and yes, our top two RBs have been injured; i don’t care. Put your game-winning players in positions where they can win the game. And that is not at RB. Gomez is mor...
Most negative
- MW29·WOLLIV-1.00I feel like that missed pass at the end from Mo is like the litmus test for how people discuss him and the rest of our attack.
His only two genuine opportunities tonight came from an opposition error (which he did very well to score from) and then his own hustle (which he did very poorly to mess up) - the last time he scored a PL goal was the EXACT same story: gifted by Emi Martinez.
Listen, Mo should have done better, I agree with you all, but he’s a high volume attacker and always has been. Tonight is not the first time we’ve seen Mo mess up an easy chance but score a much harder one.
The difference is that Mo isn’t a high volume attacker anymore. He isn’t even a medium volume attack...
- MW31·BHALIV-0.99We lost the game here when Jones was brought on for Ekitike.
It should have been Rio, and later Jones on for Gakpo in the 2nd half.
The squad not being prepared for this match and not rotated or protected by our very own coach is astonishing!
Szobo, Macca, Kerkez, Frimpong were all spent in this match. Am sorry to say but Frimpong is a great player but not suited for the defense in the PL with his physique. Yikes it feels weird to even say it out loud.
Wirtz didn’t have support and couldn’t provide it either, certainly not made easier by Gakpo’s uselessness. Man is stealing a living this season!! AND NOT BEING DROPPED LIKE WHAT MAGIC IS HE PULLING OFF IN TRAINING THAT SLOT REFUSES T...
- MW20·FULLIV-0.98Wirtz’s fitness issue needs to be sorted out asap. We’re at a dilemma right now with him where he could be the worst player on the pitch, but we look completely lost unable to circulate possession when he comes off.
Against Fulham he had a decent performance, but he comes off and suddenly we cannot progress at all down the middle of the pitch and everything was getting funnelled to the right flank. Against Leeds he had a horrific performance, yet still when he was subbed we looked worse off without him.
He needs to stay on the pitch regularly for 90 mins, I’m tired of seeing Slot hook him around the 60-70 minute mark, as soon as that substitution happens you might as well turn off the...
Steve Mcmanaman 3,446 posts · net +3.7
Highest and lowest VADER-scoring posts mentioning Steve Mcmanaman. Compound range −1…+1.
Most positive
- MW30·LIVTOT+1.00I’ve avoided being Slot out all season long but been worn down match by match. I just can’t with it anymore. The players need to cop some responsibility for sure but the system and the tactics are not working.
Wirtz is our best playmaker but somehow keeps finding himself isolated as the furthest man forward in the box. He needs to take more shots on than he does and that is a him thing, but he shouldn’t be pressed so high when he is the one meant to be pulling strings.
Szobo is a CM, not a RB. Yes, he can play on the right, and yes, our top two RBs have been injured; i don’t care. Put your game-winning players in positions where they can win the game. And that is not at RB. Gomez is mor...
- MW27·NFOLIV+1.00I am in Australia, so often times games are at ungodly hours. Thankfully I work night shift and so I'm awake at ungodly hours. I watched every single game last season...
This season I can barely force myself to tune into games because when I do, like tonight, the football we are playing is so fucking dire and unwatchable.
It actually somewhat impresses me - the horrible football we are capable of playing despite the talent in the squad. I really don't know what the solution is, I'm not necessarily in the Slot out camp. But it really does feel like a change might be inevitable.
Mo Salah is, and will forever be, a Liverpool and Premier League legend. But fuck me if we don't desperately...
- MW28·LIVWHU+0.99Macca 10 masterclass respect ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Most negative
- MW31·BHALIV-0.99We lost the game here when Jones was brought on for Ekitike.
It should have been Rio, and later Jones on for Gakpo in the 2nd half.
The squad not being prepared for this match and not rotated or protected by our very own coach is astonishing!
Szobo, Macca, Kerkez, Frimpong were all spent in this match. Am sorry to say but Frimpong is a great player but not suited for the defense in the PL with his physique. Yikes it feels weird to even say it out loud.
Wirtz didn’t have support and couldn’t provide it either, certainly not made easier by Gakpo’s uselessness. Man is stealing a living this season!! AND NOT BEING DROPPED LIKE WHAT MAGIC IS HE PULLING OFF IN TRAINING THAT SLOT REFUSES T...
- MW29·WOLLIV-0.98i would have said uncle woy before this season, but uncle woy was just out of his depth and the game had passed him by. this guy keeps on playing favourites with gakpo, salah, and macca despite being sh!te week in and week out. this guy has us playing scared, soft, system football with passing all the way back to ali. from a corner. this guy who has been traumatised by psg's counter so bad that unless it's the perfect pass, the perfect through ball, don't bother. this guy who has been traumatised by rotating at plymouth so bad that we don't bother with the bench unless we're down a goal, and we're at panic stations.
this guy just doesn't get us. LIVERPOOL FOOTBALL CLUB HAS NEVER BEEN ABO...
- MW29·WOLLIV-0.98I guess I agree with most of it but I would not judge Macca or Jones too harshly, instead I would slate Slot. He needs to make the team play but Macca was way too isolated, so often against 2+ Wolves players and without support. I don't know where Jones was, he was close to LW at one point, then he was RB/RCM a bit later...I mean...what? It's the manager who dictates positions but Jones looked quite confused and ineffective and then indirectly caused that losing goal but he was at RB at the time and had no one to pass to.
My point is, what is even our system? We are such a mess that I would not even blame our players too much, except wingers who have been very poor all season.
It's 100%...
Roy Keane 3,152 posts · net +20.9
Highest and lowest VADER-scoring posts mentioning Roy Keane. Compound range −1…+1.
Most positive
- MW11·EVEFUL+1.00Keane has 2 Prem goals... Beto and Barry combined have 1. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
- MW2·FULMUN+1.00Please Please Please give Gary Neville a managerial job at Man Utd.....
Make Roy Keane Assistant Manager...
Just so Maguire can leak the team talk at half time and we can all have a good laugh watching it 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
- MW5·LIVEVE+1.00Pickford – Started off a big middling, with his distribution not working out too well. He cannot be blamed for either goal, and though you always want to say the GK cannot let themselves be nutmegged I don’t think you can really blame him when Ekitike had the liberty of shooting anywhere he pleased and Pickford had to prioritise looking big. In the 2nd half he improved despite not really having much to do in terms of saves. His distribution was improved and targeted cleverly towards the left, and a couple of times he made smart rushes out of the goal to secure a loose ball.
Keane – Mixed game, though not bad. Occasionally struggled with positioning and in 1v1s, and it’s noteworthy that b...
Most negative
- MW6·BREMUN-0.98Damn, I never thought I'd feel bad for Man United in my life, but here we are, just a tad bit over 10 years since SAF is no longer in charge... how quickly things change in football.
I don't think Ruben is the right coach for you, but as an outsider that follows football extremely closely, even if this manager is not the one, the main issue doesn't seem to be the coach.
Apart from the questionable management of the club overall, you don't seem to have devils from the Academy in the team anymore - players willing to die for that team are no longer incorporated in the first team. I always found it amazing how SAF managed to incorporate, I am not ashamed to say it, average players (compar...
- MW32·MUNLEE-0.98Gary Neville needs to have a word with mates Carrick and Keane to explain the Martinez sending off. Hair pulls are straight red card offences for a reason. They are often picked up by VAR rather than the on field referee
Hair pulls are ugly offences and have no place in the beautiful game. They are straight red card offences not just for the optics or for legalistic reasons.
Crucially hair pulls have potential to cause serious injury. Hair pulls directly endanger the safety of the opponent by causing sudden, violent whiplash to the neck and head. Even if not a "punch," a purposeful yank is rightly deemed excessive force and a violent act for good reason. Players and managers kn...
- MW20·EVEBRE-0.97Our transfer business has been absolutely disgraceful.
Rohl and Dibling are both just horrendous. Rohl just seems to have no ability to play with a football and Dibling is lightweight and lazy.
For all his faults, the one thing I'll give Mykolenko is that he tries to make things happen, felt like he was the only one in that first half who gave a shit, everyone else in the team was hiding.
Keane reverted back to his old self for today, Tarks has been suspect at times this season and had an awful game too.
Last thing to note is how awful the Brentford fans were. Battering us and they're absolutely silent, at least Forest tried to make a bit of noise with their poverty chanting.
Jamie Carragher 1,765 posts · net +8.4
Highest and lowest VADER-scoring posts mentioning Jamie Carragher. Compound range −1…+1.
Most positive
- MW20·LEEMUN+0.99let's expose Gary Neville's reality.
Gary Neville’s Notable Failures:
• Managerial career at Valencia (2015-2016): Appointed due to connection with owner Peter Lim; no prior experience, didn’t speak Spanish. Won only 10 of 28 games, 3 of 16 in La Liga; eliminated from cups, including 7-0 loss to Barcelona. Sacked after 4 months; described as disastrous, put him off managing forever.
• England international record: 85 caps but no major trophies; closest was Euro 96 semi-final. Personally called it “a massive waste of time” in autobiography, feeling it left a “void” compared to club success.
• Punditry criticisms: Often accused of being overly harsh, biased (e.g., towards Man United or ...
- MW20·LEEMUN+0.99@gassyinc6406 I am not avoiding the question, I was hoping you can connect the dots but since you can't, I can simplify it for you: with Amorim we have won vs Burnley and vs Brighton, games we have drew and lost recently. Amorim inherited (football heritage, google it), squad with Garnacho, Onana, Sancho and many more mediocre players, are they good enough to be Man Utd players? See where they play, how they play, if they play. We have finished 15th last season (and he inherited a squad in THAT position!), before he was sacked we were 6th, it''s called "progress" and it's not usually linear. Games we dropped points this season: Nottingham, West Ham, Everton, Wolves, we would've lost them ...
- MW4·BURLIV+0.982.8 xG from 27 shots is 0.1 xG a shot which doesn't sound compelling but it's 2.04 xG from 26 non penalty shots which is 0.08 xG a shot. That definitely speaks to an inability to create any kind of good shooting opportunity on a consistent basis. It's reasonable to call scoring when you're not being able to make good shots lucky.
For context, this is better than the Arsenal game which was some 0.05 xG per shot.
There is a difference between "Liverpool are fortunate to win" and "Liverpool are fortunate this wasn't a draw". I don't know which Carragher means but I don't see how you can argue the second sentiment is inaccurate. Winning by one goal due to a stoppage time penalty against ten...
Most negative
- MW14·NEWTOT-0.99Fuck you Joe Linton, Fuck you Jamie Carragher, Fuck you Thomas Frank, Fuck you PIF, Fuck you Daniel Levy, Fuck you Thomas Bramall, Fuck you Rodrigo Bentancur, Fuck you Aaron Ramsdale, Fuck you Jason Tindall, Fuck you Paul Tierney,
- MW14·NEWTOT-0.99Fuck you Joe Linton, Fuck you Jamie Carragher, Fuck you Thomas Frank, Fuck you PIF, Fuck you Daniel Levy, Fuck you Thomas Bramall, Fuck you Rodrigo Bentancur, Fuck you Aaron Ramsdale, Fuck you Jason Tindall, Fuck you Paul Tierney,
- MW32·MUNLEE-0.98Gary Neville needs to have a word with mates Carrick and Keane to explain the Martinez sending off. Hair pulls are straight red card offences for a reason. They are often picked up by VAR rather than the on field referee
Hair pulls are ugly offences and have no place in the beautiful game. They are straight red card offences not just for the optics or for legalistic reasons.
Crucially hair pulls have potential to cause serious injury. Hair pulls directly endanger the safety of the opponent by causing sudden, violent whiplash to the neck and head. Even if not a "punch," a purposeful yank is rightly deemed excessive force and a violent act for good reason. Players and managers kn...
Paul Scholes 720 posts · net +17.5
Highest and lowest VADER-scoring posts mentioning Paul Scholes. Compound range −1…+1.
Most positive
- MW24·MUNFUL+1.00I have really good point for the UNITED BOARD to be seriously considering to appoint Michael Carrick the be permanent manager. Here is the reason...remember the best united squad ever 2008-2009? Ronaldo,Rooney,van der sar, scholes,giggs,vidic,ji sung, and etc... actually the one who make them all to perform on their best ability is... Michael Carrick..he..carrick..can bring out the best from every each one of them..and Now ..here in 2026...the same things happen to our current united squad... just at this time..carrick not as CM/DM for united..but as MANCHESTER UNITED MANAGER. Trust me... players love him, supporters love him, i bet ferguson also like him as our manager.. So..united boa...
- MW20·LEEMUN+0.99let's expose Gary Neville's reality.
Gary Neville’s Notable Failures:
• Managerial career at Valencia (2015-2016): Appointed due to connection with owner Peter Lim; no prior experience, didn’t speak Spanish. Won only 10 of 28 games, 3 of 16 in La Liga; eliminated from cups, including 7-0 loss to Barcelona. Sacked after 4 months; described as disastrous, put him off managing forever.
• England international record: 85 caps but no major trophies; closest was Euro 96 semi-final. Personally called it “a massive waste of time” in autobiography, feeling it left a “void” compared to club success.
• Punditry criticisms: Often accused of being overly harsh, biased (e.g., towards Man United or ...
- MW29·NEWMUN+0.99It’s embarrassing that Scholes is saying this, but tbh I hope this was a wake up call for everyone wanting Carrick to take over.
United havent played good at all the last few games, but everybody just looks at those first two wins and see them as enough. Brilliant performance against city and arsenal but we usually do well vs the good teams. It’s always been the mid table / bottom table teams we struggle with and the lowblocks. Carrick has showed that he can’t handle them (at least so far but with that being the biggest issue you’d think he’d have a plan for it by now especially after his winning streak). 10 man Newcastle scores 2 against us and we get a pen which was controversial to m...
Most negative
- MW29·NEWMUN-0.96There’s the creeping sense of irrelevance that’s haunting them, but both Butt and Scholes quickly found out that their new podcast platform opened the doors to criticism and they HATE it.
Whenever something fits their bizarre criticism, they have to smugly say or post something like “I told you so”. But even a broken clock is right twice a day.
- MW29·NEWMUN-0.92Does Scholes know this is the first match lost under Carrick or is he just a stupid, miserable twat?
- MW20·LEEMUN-0.92It is not worth mentioning Jamie C, I lost total respect for Scholes totally, Gary Neville another piece of crap, if the board gave RA what he asked for it would've been a totally different scenario, he wanted Ollie W they gave him Sesko and they could've kept Hojlaand and we'd have 2 strikers nothing wrong with Sesko but he doesn't fit the system or his taking too long too settle in, also how are we 3rd highest scorers in only 20 games in the league, how are we in 6th position if RA did not improve. I love RA and I stand with him, it took Alex Furgerson a longtime to build man u he had the time and the backing RA did not these Nevilles, Scholes and all these wannabe critics or social med...